r/AllThemWitches

It’s my birthday. 49 years old asf. I want everyone to play your damn ATW playlist extra loud today!!!

I'm ready to give my ratings index. First of all, I love the record, there are no bad songs on it, just good and great. I think it's one of their best albeit a different style then their previous stuff. I think they're aiming for more hooky sounds and riffs this time and it pays off on almost all of it, their talent for creating awesome music is undeniable. Ben is the man, absolute genius. He and MPJ are magical together, no disrespect to the others.

I won't rank the songs individually, but I'll organize them in tiers

Tier S

2 songs that I think stand out above and beyond everything else:

Saturn Song, Culling Line

Tier A

Red Rocking Chair, The Welterweight, Go Getter, Starting Line

Tier B

Turn on the light, Angel On The Wayside

Tier C

Aethernet, Hold Up, Say What?

Just my opinion in the order of songs that actually give the best visceral, emotional reactions. ATW are great at that.

This should be released as an Live Album just like the first Ancienne Belgique show.
They sound absolutely amazing in this.
Diamond performance is mind blowing and the transition to 1x1 is stunning.

[Appreciation post!]

I was not yet convinced of the new album but they do sound amazing when they play it live, like almost everything they created.

Saw them about 8 months ago and yesterday and both were killer shows.

Also loved the bands picked for the opening acts, it is such a treat when these are bands whose own show would be worth it already.
Elder last year, yesterday we got Rezn and Slomosa.

Alabaster - All Them Witches

Title pretty much is the question.. all the albums have a unique sound and the band is so diverse imo but curious as to what others think is their definitive sound if it had to be a single song?

I was probably in the group that was slightly disappointed at first and it definitely took a few listens for House of Mirrors to fully click for me, but man.. it really is another outstanding album.

A bit more "classic rock" in sound and feel compared to their previous albums I think, but it's All Them Witches and it's awesome.

Go Getter hasn’t been played on any of the recent House of Mirrors shows.

I wonder why? They’ve played the rest of the album most shows.

Hopefully they will in the future.

Makes me think about some of the mellower songs we’ve not heard live…Mellowing! and others

I'm so proud of the band but FUCK

SOLD OUT IN 21 minutes?!

Looking to pick up a solid raw record from All Them Witches. Their session on KEXP is always on repeat and I would prefer a studio version or a collection of their records. Any recommendations and if there is a more studio version that I can order online?