What a shame, MM will not be answered for a while
On a somewhat related note, I'm switching to MCIMM+AndrewMM (Also sorry for no Theory of the week last Sunday, I’ll make two this Sunday)
for me its surely BVTOYSNHK, genuinly dont find logic in this, and it dont fits cc, if im had a second one would be Cassidy for the same reason as CC, it dont fits her character
(Art source: Andrew!!)
It has been kinda catching my interest recently since it kind of solves Andrew not being in the games stuff, and I can see merging them being satisfying. Especially since many similarities with Andrew that BVTOYSNHK uses can as easily be interpreted as a hint that they're the same character. It also apparently has a Logbook solution too (though inconsistent and not really that strong, but admittedly creative and like all methods for name solving are inconsistent to some degree in Logbook). So I wondered y'all think of it here.
I’m going to be starting a tradition where every Sunday, I will post a Theory of the Week about Andrew and eventually UCN and Frights in general, starting with one of my favorite theories for Andrew.
What is AndrewExperiments?
AndrewExperiments is the theory that Andrew was a victim of the Nightmare experiments that William enacted to learn about Agony and its effects. The experiments take place in the Sister Location bunker, where Afton experimented on multiple children.
What is the evidence for AndrewExperiments?
UCN connections to the Nightmare Experiments:
In UCN, we play as William Afton, who is being put in an endless nightmare by TOYSNHK, a person who was extremely vengeful at William killing him and putting him through hell. In “Dittophobia,” we are told that Afton repeatedly put the experiment victims through hell and replayed the same night over and over, which is exactly what TOYSNHK does in UCN.
Moreover, in UCN, the FNAF 4 bedroom is the only one that doesn’t have elements from other offices, making it unique and special to TOYSNHK, and in Stingers, Andrew states, “I remember I wanted him to suffer, the way he made me suffer.”
AndrewMM:
Under AndrewMM, it is very possible that Andrew was kidnapped by William and lured to the chambers to be experimented on.
TCHSYMCI:
In Toy Chica High School Years, the very final victim is Pigpatch. Toy Chica drives up to Pigpatch, hits him with a shovel, and drives off with him. Unlike the other victims, Toy Chica never takes him to her house, which represents the Safe Room, showing William could’ve taken him somewhere else.
What are the problems with AndrewExperiments?
In UCN, there are multiple instances and things TOYSNHK wouldn’t have known about. This could show that TOYSNHK doesn’t need to know about the experiments.
In Stingers, Andrew has zero recollection of how he died and doesn’t remember what Afton did to him.
• Stingers happen after UCN, which is before Andrew’s soul was split, possibly meaning he did know his death before splitting.
There is a lot suggesting Midnight Motorist is about the Aftons and not Andrew.
In TCHSY, Pigpatch could represent someone else.
• There is no other William Afton victim that fits Pigpatch’s death.
for me, its AndrewOMC, i don't believe it but i like its story potential.
