Car Dilemma: 2019 Honda Civic or 2020 Mazda 3?
I'm completely torn between two cars and could really use some advice. I'm coming from an MG ZS Hybrid, so I'm used to the instant response of an electric motor, and I'm looking to switch to a hatchback. One requirement is non-negotiable: it has to be an automatic.
I've found two options on Autohero and can't decide which one to choose.
1. 2020 Mazda 3 2.0 Skyactiv-G (122 hp) – Zenith Trim
Pros:
- A year newer.
- Lower mileage (~77,000 km).
- Traditional 6-speed torque converter automatic transmission.
- I generally prefer the sound and character of a naturally aspirated engine.
Cons:
- I'm worried it might feel a bit sluggish coming from a hybrid with instant torque.
- I'm considering a Stage 1 tune to unlock the engine to around 165 hp, since it's mechanically the same engine as the higher-output version.
2. 2019 Honda Civic 1.5 VTEC Turbo (182 hp) – Prestige Trim
Pros:
- I slightly prefer the styling.
- Plenty of power (182 hp), so performance should never be an issue.
Cons:
- It costs about €2,300 more.
- Higher mileage (~85,000 km).
- The biggest concern is the CVT transmission. One thing that's important to me is enjoying the engine and exhaust sound when accelerating, and I've heard that the CVT tends to keep the engine at a constant RPM, creating that "drone" or "scooter" effect, which really takes away from the driving experience.
- The extra equipment on this trim (leather seats and sunroof) isn't particularly important to me.
My dilemma:
Which one would you choose?
The Honda Civic for its stronger engine and styling, despite the CVT potentially ruining the driving sound and feel? Or the Mazda 3, possibly tuned to around 165 hp, with a conventional automatic transmission, a more natural engine sound, and potentially lower long-term maintenance costs, even if it doesn't have the same low-end turbo punch?
I'd really appreciate any opinions or first-hand experience with either of these automatic models. Thanks!