r/SAINTSATINESNARKPAGE

Is it just me or have Emily's vocals stayed as poor as they were in Dream Academy, or even worsened?

I was re-watching the ANTIFRAGILE mission from Dream Academy after I watched party b4 the party, and she still has the same shaky, flat vocals. Seeing as one of her major issues were her vocals, I would've thought there would have at least been some lessons and training. She's had (give or take) 2 years of training for SS/Prelude so why are her vocals still unstable, even before she's dancing?

My guess is that HxG have tried their best to make the girls look like a harmonious girl group, instead of working individually with each girl on their weaknesses and worst attributes. To be honest, it's really HxG's fault if anyone's for not fixing her vocals before debut seeing as they've had this long to rehearse, practice and grind the girls to where they need to be; she doesn't need dancing help at all, she's an amazing dancer, so why are her vocals still so bad??

pb4tp is very obviously a song about pre-gaming-- who thought it would be a good idea to give this song to the line-up with a 16 year old in it??

i know it's normal for kpop groups to be handed songs without having any involvement in the songwriting process, but what usually makes up for it is that the songs match the vibe or 'story' of the group in such a way that it's believable for them to be singing it. internet girl for example (even though it was a bad song) is believable coming from a group like katseye bc everyone knows they're chronically online, it makes sense. a 16 year old with a sheltered upbringing (who honestly looks and sounds even younger IMO) singing about pregaming and then going out for a night on the town is just so unbelievable to me like even if the vocals were better i wouldn't be able to take this song seriously coming from them 😭

i will not be streaming lol. why did they not keep prelude as 3!!

So I was scrolling on twitter as usual and I saw some comments saying “Sakura is my bias 🥺” which made me fall to the floor laughing bc wdym ur fav is a minor who cannot sing or dance and rigged a competition to get a spot in a group with 20 year olds? Like what? They have to be bots

wtf is JINGJINGALING
WHY
NO LYRIC IN THAT SONG MATCHES THE PREVIOUS ONE ITS A BUNCH OF RANDOM LINES THAT MAKE NO SENSE

ALL BLACK SHADES ON
PUT THAT REV ON
REVOLUTION
FLICK THAT FLICK THAT????

Flick what

Party before the party
More like
Dying before I actually die

I’m sorry I just don’t get the song, and the constant 💨💨💨💨 in the live performance just puts me off

Other people framed it well- the final performance showed two paths, the RnB route with two good singers (we ride), or fast beat slop lyric music (PB4P). They didn't choose the vocalist who can make the group RnB, so they will probably focus on making fast paced dancing songs because they aren't capable of performing RnB live. Prepare for more Pinky Ups, Internet Girls, and a flopped group. Katseye is getting carried by controversy, but these girls don't even have enough personality to be controversial, they have to actively work to call eachother sloths, like weird videos, and exaggerating the lack of education of a member to stay relevant. The dumbass fans who get off on defending a group because people on "hating a minor" are playing into these companies hands.

i was so surprised listening to this. it has way more flavor and is actually listenable lol. it feels way more put together than saint satine’s kidz bop.. thing

curious how sakura’s version of we ride will turn out since she’s so off key…