u/Aggressive_Team_861

▲ 1 r/plotholes+1 crossposts

"If Wishes Could Kill" - The BIGGEST plothole. How did the makers not answer this??

So I just finished watching "If Wishes Could Kill" and I was just going through reddit to see how people are reacting on the show.

And while doing so, a moment in the show just clicked in my mind and I noticed no one is talking about it. So I thought I should make a post about it.

Sooo... I don't remember the episode, but it was the whole flashback story when Hye-Ryung records her wish on the girigo app, not to be mentioned, the FIRST EVER wish video on the app.

The app was NOT cursed till this moment.

As the show CLEARLY reveal that after Si-Won wishes on the app to keep the curse going FOREVER.

So when Si-Won and that guy who Hye-Ryung liked gets killed on their own...how did that happen?

So if the cursed started AFTER this incident then how did Si-Won and that guy died? Who was controlling them?

I don't think it was Hye-Rung's spirit who killed them because then the whole plot gets even more confusing that who is the real killer here... Hye-Rung's spirit, the curse that started after Si-Won's wish OR was the app really working how it was made to work.

And if yes then again another question arises that how does the app work, and all this hye-rung and Si-Won story plays a completely different storyline, the one that is shown to us. NOT how the app works (if it does work)

Maybe I have lost any detail while watching the show and that's why I am posting this. Let's see what you guys have to tell.

reddit.com
u/Aggressive_Team_861 — 13 days ago