Milo original creepypasta by Asher Muirlock
I worked as a police officer. I was told that someone named Jack Dather died after falling off the town bridge. A kid in the area saw it go down. His mother was the one who reported it. I was asked to talk to the kid to confirm if it was a suicide or an accident. I believe they said his name was Milo. I was bored of always being stuck giving out speeding tickets. I jumped at the opportunity to do something different.
When I arrived, the room was cold and empty. The only thing inside was an old desk, me, and Milo sitting on the other side. I slowly sat down and said, “My name is Jacob. I am here to ask you some questions.”
Milo didn’t seem to notice me. His face was completely empty, and any sense of emotion was hollow. He had short hair. He had emerald green eyes, but the lighting made them look grey. He was short. I was told he was twelve. His height made him look eight.
After a moment to clear my voice, I softly said, “Hey, they said your name is Milo. I am here to ask you some questions about what happened today at the bridge.” Milo turned to look at me. He was still completely expressionless. His eyes blinked very slowly. He stood completely still. He was nothing like what his colorful red and orange T-shirt would suggest.
There was no way to tell if anything was going through his mind other than static. He was as silent as a dead mouse. He barely moved; he just stood there. He just looked off into nothing. After no response, I said, “Don’t worry, you are not in trouble. I just want to ask you about what happened to Jack.”
He again said nothing in response, just his cold, lifeless face tilting towards me. I waved my hand toward him and slowly said, “Is everything alright, Milo? Are you okay? Do you not feel comfortable talking about what happened today?”
He finally broke his silence and began to slowly nod at me. I nodded back. When I looked back, he didn't stop; he just kept doing it. It was slow, almost alien how lifelessly his body moved. After nearly a minute of him nodding back and forth, he said, “Okay, what do you want?”
I softly said in response, “When and where did you see Jack?” For a few seconds, I saw his face finally have an expression. There was a sense of fear in his eyes. Milo then looked down toward the ground as he quietly said, “I was just playing a game and I saw Jack pass by.”
I waved my hand at him and began once again, “Was the game near the town bridge? How close were you to the bridge when the accident happened.” He said in an even quieter voice, “Yes I was playing on the bridge. I was there. I saw it happen.”
I looked at him solemnly and a frown slowly covered my face as I spoke, “I’m sorry you had to see that. It is such a shame someone so young had to see something so horrific.” His hands started shaking the second I stopped speaking. His hands went from completely still to moving at ungodly speed in just a few seconds. His eyes were twitching. He looked like he was about to have a panic attack.
I reached into my pocket and quickly pulled out my phone and said, “This is going to be over soon. Your mom would not have let you do this if it wasn’t safe. Everything will go back to normal when I am done asking you questions. If you feel unsafe, I can call your parents.”
“Don’t. I'm fine answering your questions, just don’t call my parents. I don’t want them to know,” he immediately said in return. I immediately said, “Your parents already know about our conversation. Your mom was the one who reported Jack's body.” Milo froze. He stopped blinking. It was hard to tell if he was breathing.
“You aren’t in trouble, I just really need some questions answered. Your mom contacted us about you. She said she wants us to talk to you about what happened today. Are you fine answering my questions?
His face turned to anger when his mother was mentioned. He nodded in return as I finished speaking. His hands briefly turned into fists before returning to normal. He was clearly trying to hide his frustration. I was about to ask him about it but I stopped and just stuck to what I was supposed to talk about.
“What was Jack doing when you saw him?” Milo responded instantly, this time he didn’t hide his anger, his eyes were burning with anger, “He was being a jerk.” I snapped back with, “How?” Milo didn’t wait another second before saying, “He tried to beat me up. He did that all the time when I was alone at the park.”
His hands slowly moved into fists. He looked as if he was ready to punch someone before switching back to his empty state. I nodded at him as I said, “How long was that before he jumped? How long was he doing that kind of thing?”
His expression was still empty but his voice was strangely happy, even excited as he spoke, “Years, he did that to me for years. He was about to do it again before he fell.” I looked back, concerned as I said, “What was the last thing Jack did before he jumped? Did something seem off to you?”
Milo looked back as a smile slowly began to tear open his once expressionless face. He started shaking his legs under the table not nervously but joyfully. He then said in a clear calm voice, “He tried to punch me before he fell off.”
My concern only grew as I slowly and nervously said, “Did he slip or jump off? Did Jack die after he tripped trying to punch you?” He looked back at me, his face went into an impression of his previous emotionally empty state. He then slowly said, “Can we move on to the next question? I don’t like this one. What else do you want to know?” His hands began to shake again. His legs were still shaking under the table but this time nervously.
I slapped my hand on the table. As I pulled my hand back, I said, this time louder, “Did he slip or jump off the bridge?” Everything about the look on Milo's face changed as I waved my hand. He stared off at the wall like I was not there. His face somehow looked less lifeless than usual but still terrified. He looked scared.
I quickly said as I saw him start to stand up, ready to scream, “Sorry for raising my voice. I just really need to find out what happened to Jack. We need to confirm his cause of death. Can you please just answer my questions?”
He slowly nervously said, “No, you don’t.” I stared at him with horror growing in my eyes as I said, “Why?” He didn’t flinch an inch as he spoke, “You don’t want to know. It's better if you never know,” he said. “What happened at the bridge?” I shouted. He said nothing in response other than an, ‘No.’ “I said, what happened at the bridge," I screamed.
Milo looked at me and spoke in a quiet horrified voice. “I didn’t mean for Emily to die. I just wanted her to stop.” A smile crossed his face when he said stop. I heard about Emily before she went missing a few months ago. I blankly said, “I asked about Jack, not Emily. What did you do?”
Milo looked at me, his hands were violently shaking as he said, “She fell off too.” I immediately shouted, "You said you didn’t mean for Emily to die, how could she have fallen off if you said it was an accident on your part. Did you push them off?"
Milo coldly said, “It was an accident on her part. It was all her.” I screamed out, “Did you really think I would believe that happened twice? Your story does not line up. You are telling me you saw two people fall off a bridge on two separate occasions. You didn't report it the first time, your mother reported it the second time after she saw him fall from across the park and it was not your fault despite claiming it was an accident.”
Milo said in return, “When I said ‘accident,’ I was talking about her; she accidentally tripped. They both died because of their mistakes. It was all them.” He slammed his hand on the desk when he said their mistakes. I didn’t argue in response. Instead, I looked off to the door as I said, “I'm leaving. I’m telling someone about this.”
Milo almost immediately ran in front of the door. He then coldly said, “You don’t want to tell anyone about our conversation.” I looked down at him. He looked angry, his small hands in fists, he had his mouth open ready to scream. I then told him, “Move.”
He didn't; instead, he just screamed. I screamed back at him, “This whole conversation is being recorded. Just calm down or—”
The door opened, and who walked through was one of my coworkers. He said, “They found another body below the bridge. We think it's Emily.” I said nothing. I just stared at Milo. Milo then said, “It was their mistake. They all had it coming. I did nothing wrong, I would do it all again if I could.” That was when I realized that Milo was not a normal kid; he was a cold-blooded killer.