I have fine, dense, dry, coily, unrelaxed hair and I'm searching for a lightweight but extremely moisturizing styling custard, jelly, or other product to use over leave-in conditioner. Super cheap options or cheaper dupes of products I’ve used that worked (listed below) would be helpful (shopping from Canada btw). Doesn’t have to be catered/marketed toward natural hair as long as it works and it'll keep my hair decently moisturized.
Both salons I’ve been to said that because my hair is fine, it's best to avoid products where oils/butters are the main ingredients. Instead, I should look for products with humectants as the main ingredients. This advice has worked for me so I'm looking to avoid heavy butters or oils and focus on humectants (though sometimes if the product lists water and humectants first and oil/butter is lower on the ingredients list, it's ok. My old favourite leave-in had soybean oil as the 5th ingredient and the custard I used it with has linseed oil as the 5th ingredient and those worked well together on me). Heavy stuff will weigh my hair down or not let moisture get attracted to my hair.
By the way, I don't really care about definition, hold, or frizz. I'm just looking to keep my hair moisturized for as long as possible. The moisture from using a leave in conditioner by itself wasn't lasting as long as using leave-in conditioner with a moisturizing styling product on top so that's why I'm looking for both.
I think I might have low porosity since my hair takes hours to fully dry, but that might just be because my hair is super dense. I think I got different answers when I did the water test thing so idk.
My usual routine (when I have the energy) is shampoo, rinse-out conditioner, leave in conditioner, then a styling product once a week. Once a month I use a clarifying shampoo. Between wash days if my hair is getting dry, I sometimes co-wash, leave-in, then styling product, so one wash day per week and one co wash day per week at most. I listed some products that have and haven't worked on me in case that helps.
What's working
Shampoo
Design Essentials Almond & Avocado Moisturizing & Detangling Sulfate-Free Shampoo (favourite) (current)
Tressame Rich Moisture Shampoo for Dry Hair
Rinse out conditioner
Tressame **Rich Moisture Conditioner for Dry Hair (current) -** what I use to co-wash and condition
Design essentials, **Almond & Avocado Moisturizing & Detangling Conditioner** (favourite)
Design essentials, Rosemary & Mint Stimulating Super Moisturizing Conditioner
Redken Acidic Color Gloss Sulfate-Free Conditioner
leave in conditioner
Kerasoft Revival Curl Revitalizer (favorite, but it seems to have gotten discontinued)
Mielle Pomegranate & Honey Leave-In Conditioner (current)
Design essentials African Chebe Anti-Breakage Moisturizing Leave-In Conditioner - this one’s a question mark, they used it on me for a wash and go in the salon and I remember it feeling fine but I haven't tried using it long term
Custard/moisturizing styling product
Patterns Styling Custard- for some reason, this made my hair feel dry when I used it by itself but worked really well with the Kerasoft Revival Curl Revitalizer
Design essentials **Curl Defining Gelée** (favourite, but expensive and hard to get)
Mielle honey pomegranate coil sculpting custard (current, decent moisture but leaves flakes/chunks)
What didn’t work
Aunt Jackie’s Quench! Moisture Intensive Leave-In Conditioner
Aunt Jackie’s Curl La La Defining Curl Custard
Aussie Kids Curly Leave-In Conditioner for Kids
**CurlEssence Coconut Curling Jelly** - question mark because I tried it once and it mixed decently with the Mielle Pomegranate & Honey Leave-In Conditioner, but the jelly felt oily so I had a feeling it would feel dry in the morning. I ended up rinsing it out and trying something else so I haven't tried it for a full day yet
Aunt Jackie’s Curl boss coconut curling gelee and **Don't Shrink Flaxseed Elongating Curling Gel* both technically worked on me since they added definition and i think that's their main purpose, but they didn't add any significant extra moisture and definition isn't that necessary for me, so that's why I am not using them
Stuff I considered trying but didn’t (if you have experience with these products, let me know how they worked for keeping your hair moisturized for a long time, especially if you have fine and/or dry hair
Hawaiian silky gel activator
BEE GIRL Honey Curl Custard 16oz
Mielle Pomegranate & Honey Curl Smoothie
Mielle Pomegranate & Honey Twisting Soufflé
Mielle Rosemary mint strengthening leave-in conditioner
Mielle Rosemary Mint daily styling creme
Mielle honey pomegranate honey ginger styling gel