Rules for the tier list

1. We are assuming the Twisted won't attack once FULLY INSIDE the Elevator
2. We are taking into account a full team of Toons and Trinkets
3. We are assuming the floor has ONLY that specific Twisted to minimize randomness (unless said Twisted comes with other Twisted)

feel free to ask for specifics!

Note(s)

I only included the full-body renders

In case the image didn't load; here are the results:

THE BEST RENDERS

• Eclipse (97/100)
• Reef Explorer Finn (96/100)
• Golden Wings Flyte (95/100)
• Soulvester (94/100)
• Vee-ster Bunny Vee (93/100)

Great Renders

• Ribecca (92/100)
• Strawberry Paws Cocoa (91/100)
• Cheer Bear Shelly (90/100)
• Gourdy (89/100)
• Garden Bouquet Scraps (89/100)
• Golden Bauble Bobette (88/100)
• Share Bear Cosmo (88/100)
• Bedtime Bear Astro (87/100)
• Golden Antlers Rudie (86/100)
• Wish Bear Gigi (86/100)
• Tenderheart Bear Sprout (85/100)
• Garden Blossoms Goob (85/100)
• Grumpy Bear Shrimpo (84/100)

Good Renders

• Hot Chocolate Bobette (83/100)
• Golden Cookie Ginger (82/100)
• Pastel Patterns Looey (82/100)
• Chef Sprout (81/100)
• Golden Fishbowl Finn (81/100)
• Golden Berry Sprout (80/100)
• Golden Bunny Cocoa (79/100)
• Golden Dust Coal (78/100)
• Crinkled Confetti Yatta (77/100)
• Egg Hunting Bassie (75/100)
• New Years Ginger (74/100)
• Brightney (73/100)
• Dandy (72/100)
• Pebble (71/100)
• Gigi (70/100)

Ok Renders

• Flyte (69/100)
• Yatta (69/100)
• Golden Egg Eggson (68/100)
• Dyle (68/100)
• Golden Basket Bassie (67/100)
• Bobette (66/100)
• Rodger (66/100)
• Shelly (65/100)
• Coal (65/100)
• Cocoa (65/100)
• Scraps (65/100)
• Rudie (64/100)
• Goob (64/100)
• Brusha (64/100)
• Ginger (63/100)
• Astro (63/100)
• Bassie (62/100)
• Squirm (61/100)
• Eggson (60/100)

Meh Renders

• Sprout - Old Render (58/100)

Bad Renders

• none

Terrible Renders

• none

Random Poppy: "So... why can't we just sneak behind them?"

My Gigi: "Because we can't"

Random Poppy: "That... doesn't answer my question, though."

Wish Bear Gigi: "I don't know... I just go along with what Rodger's Research says to do: 'Don't run'."

Random Poppy: ...

My Gigi: ...

Random Poppy: "Ok... why can't we just throw stuff at them.

My Gigi: "He's looking right at us."

Random Poppy: "And? We can just go behind him-"

My Gigi: "He can hear us."

Random Poppy: "-and attack from 2 angles"

My Gigi: "He has 2 heads."

Random Poppy: "Are you trying to help?"

My Gigi: ...

Random Poppy: ...

My Gigi: *Uses ability and takes out Stealth Candy*

Random Poppy: "Gigi, I swear to god."

note: This is the 1st time I've free-drawn a quadrupedal character standing on all-fours, so please forgive if it looks awkward </3

Note: he has leaf-shaped wings :3

edit: just realized I didn't include the relationship and card stuff, I'll put that with the Twisted post

Lore

Everything went wrong for Note today: first, a random user's Shrimpo had broken her headphones, then she was called by Victor to get his shotgun. She doesn't know why, but she assumed it was probably to make a joke for the other avatars. However, when she entered the subreddit, something was immediately off. Everything was... pitch black and silent.

After a bit of wandering, she eventually spotted 2 equally confused avatars: Moderator FxNN and Dukar. Together, the 3 walked about, trying to find anyone; Another OC, another Avatar, even a Toonsona or redesigned Toon.
Then they saw a light... In that light was Victor... T̵͔̕h̵̢͠e̴̝̓ÿ̴̹́ ̸̗̽m̴͉͒å̶̻d̸̺͋e̴̛̹ ̸̦̌ṯ̵͒h̵̖͗ȩ̶͋ ̷̣͆m̴͖̈́ï̴̻ṣ̶̂t̶̼͋ă̸̗k̷̥̾e̶̩͘ ̶͍̏ỏ̷͕f̴̲̿ ̶͛͜à̵͚p̷̭̌p̶̙̃r̷̩͛o̴͓̿à̷͙c̴̯̎ḩ̶͆ị̵̽ṉ̶̅g̷̪͒ ̷̪̔h̴̫͐i̵̜̍m̵̮͗.̷̈́͜.̶̮̊

Before another could succumb to the darkness, FxNN slashed his axe at Victor, ready to fight only for more characters to show up, each looking just as messed up and corrupted. This wasn't going to be a regular fight against a 1-time glitch; it was going to be a war for the Subreddit's survival.

Seeing as it couldn't get his shotgun, the Darkness moved Victor back and sent a sword-wielding Bassie to fight the survivors

One can only hope the other Moderator Avatars caught on as quickly as FxNN did... for now, they just have to deal with the 1 holding the dangerous remote.

Credits

The cursor: ME! I'M WATCHING THE CHAOS, UNABLE TO DO ANYTHING ABOUT IT! :DDD (What? Ya think this is Animator Vs. Animation?)
V̷̠̀i̶͎̿c̷̝̉ẗ̶̩́o̷͔̚r̴̺͗: My main Avatar (This is the 1st time I've PROPERLY drawn him from a side profile... I think I did ok but definitely could've looked better. Chose him over my reddit Avatar cause she's already featured twice by default)
Note: My OC (yep, she's tall! ... for a child toon... considering she's a cria, imagine her as an adult toon!)
Freed Flutter (hidden behind rules): My Fluttersona (don't look behind her ;D)
Dukar: u/OwnMud6375's avatar/?OC? (easiest to draw... though, as powerful as he is, I doubt running headfirst into something that can corrupt the likes of Bugs Bunny will do anything TOT)
FxNN: u/FxNNtheFishbowl's version/avatar (unless missing a post, I never really see him draw his own art... so I sort of just did an in general art style.)
B̴̧̉ä̸̢́ŝ̵̙s̷̰̀i̵͓̐ȅ̷̺: u/GreatCover3442's version
M̶͉̀ȏ̴̺r̷̖͌ǐ̶͈b̷̢̓ų̶̔n̷̜̆d̵̤̏ ̶̭̃B̶͈̀ṙ̶̤i̴̝͋g̸͙͑ḧ̷͖́t̵̍ͅn̴̺̍é̸̢y̸͆͜: u/JOHN_dingle6969's version (his art style is surprisingly similar to mine! just less rigid than mine ^^)

The ones I wanted to add but couldn't for various reasons

P̸̘̕h̴̞̾o̴̝̕l̴̗̑ì̸̪ą̵̈́: DekoLekoHecco's OC, scraped for lack of confirmation or denial of allowance to draw OC, sorry Deko
M̴̤̓ę̶͝s̵̞̐ś̸͎ȳ̷̨: Hext0pily's Bassiesona, scraped 'cause I didn't know where to put them ta make 'em look good, sorry Hext0pily, I really did wanna add them :(
Sara Sarai: The_Biggest_Tree_74's OC, same situation as M̴̤̓ę̶͝s̵̞̐ś̸͎ȳ̷̨, sorry Tree </3

hmmmm

OH I KNOW!

IT'S HIS ANTLERS' STRIPE COUNT!

Let's say for this hypothetical scenario, Delilah and Arthur didn't create Ichor and just gone with the standard costumes and animatronics

Rules:

1. HAS TO BE MATERIALS THAT REPLICATE WHAT THE TOONS ARE, Delilah and Arthur care about details ^n^
2. We are assuming the animatronics are advanced enough to walk around and interact with others and won't mind the costumes existing.
3. We are assuming the suits have decent facial animation aided by something in the backstage
4. We're taking into account ALL the skins and most of the abilities

My reasoning/notes for a bunch of them

Flutter: Would mostly have to be sitting while active to avoid the extra cost of rigging something to make it look like she's flying, hence being lower than Flyte

Yatta: Would've gotten slightly higher, but her tails would require special robot-pieces to grab things (Guess What I Eat Yatta). I do think they're able to pull it off, though, for both the suit (controlled backstage) and the animatronic pieces

Looey: Would be in the highest tier, but I doubt people would find all his squeaking-while-moving fun after a while

Poppy: Flexible glass is a real thing, just need enough to hide the endoskeleton/wearer

Tisha/Scraps: paper... at least with Yatta papier-mâché can be molded and dried, Tisha and Scraps have to be made of thick pieces of paper or cardboard.

Bassie: wicker basket, simple enough... but then we get to the flowers. According to Google Gemini, the flowers Bassie normally has closely resemble African Violets, which are typically 5-petaled. Assuming this is true... well... I'll just let Microsoft Copilot talk "Expect to spend roughly $50–$300 in one‑time supplies and $5–$20/month ongoing to breed and maintain African violets while attempting a naturally occurring 4‑petal variant; if you use mutation techniques (radiation/chemicals) costs rise, and timelines shorten but require specialist access and permits." This isn't even going over her other skins... Bassie's model and suit are not the problem; it's the cost of the flowers that brought her down.

Connie: Similar to Flutter, except they need several excuses to avoid needing to move around or disappear

Brightney: animatronic during blackout [all fine ;D] suit during blackout [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OxSBnjUG_l0]

Ribecca: Skeleton, works perfectly for being an animatronic, not so much as a proper suit. A lot of modifications would likely need to be made for the suit version, but it isn't impossible.

Vee: I know what you're thinking... "But wolf! Delilah and Arthur would like their characters to be as accurate as possible! Wouldn't a suit version be a bad idea because of the lack of facial features!?" My counterpoint: The earliest documented use of facial tracking for animated headwear appears in James Cameron’s The Abyss from 1989. It's entirely possible for these 2 to make a Vee suit ^^

Gigi: I doubt kids would like to see a HEAD INSIDE GIGI

Rodger: Do... do I have to explain what a magnifying glass is?

Razzle & Dazzle: While I do know multi-limbed suits exist, I doubt anyone can make 2 heads look convincing (Edit 2: The suit version COULD WORK with 2 smaller people)

Astro: Being the 2nd/3rd most important character (best friend to Dandy), he is basically REQUIRED to be more animated than the others

Eclipse: P-please put the pitchforks and torches down, let me explain TwT
NORMALLY, she would be up in the top tier... but she isn't a normal wolf! SHE IS A WEREWOLF! That alone isn't the issue... but the fact she gets bigger when transforming into her werewolf form is!

Blot: made of ink

Finn: 2 issues; 1st water, 2nd Barnaby. The water issue is self-explanatory, but not the main 1. The Barnaby issue is; the first known animatronic designed to operate underwater was the Dolphin Robotic Unit (DRU), developed in the early 2000s. While I do think Delilah and Arthur CAN come up with a way to make Animatronic Barnaby properly exist, I doubt they'll risk delaying Gardenview's opening after the "Bassie's Flowers" incident. (Edit 1: I was wrong with this fact, but I'd still say it'd be hard to make a self-moving, living, underwater animatronic that's around Barnaby's size)

Teagan: Tea needs to be heated. How do you heat the tea without overheating the Animatronic Teagan? Plus you're wasting so much tea! At least with Finn you can dump the water into a creek or lake, but TEAGAN NEEDS TO HAVE TEA TO BE TEAGAN.

HELLO?

HELLO

HELLO

HELLO

Feel free to ask for clarification :3

*braces for hate, just in case*

Be as brutal as you want, just don't get banned :3

This is a sneak peek to some art :3

This looks so weirdly cute! ;w;