u/Cautious_Ad6

Hey folks, need some guidance on a tricky situation.

I interviewed with two companies — let’s call them Company A and Company B.

Company B is closely related to Company A (like a subsidiary/client relationship), so they have some internal visibility into hiring.

Here’s what happened:

- I've accepted Company A offer & next day it all happened.

- Company A gave me an offer of 11 LPA (fixed)

- Company B verbally/over email confirmed 13 LPA (fixed) (no official offer letter yet)

Then things got complicated:

- Company A HR noticed duplicate processes internally and spoke to me

- Company B HR also discussed compensation and said they’d resolve things internally

- After that, communication from Company B has gone silent, and I suspect they assumed I’d go ahead with Company A

Now:

- I only have Company A’s official offer (11 LPA) in hand

- But I did have a confirmed higher offer (13 LPA) from Company B earlier

---

My questions:

  1. Can I still use that 13 LPA discussion/confirmation to negotiate with Company A?

  2. How do I bring this up without sounding like I’m bluffing (since I don’t have a formal offer letter)? But I think Company A knows about it.

  3. Given both companies are connected, could this backfire if I push for a match?

  4. What’s the best way to phrase this to HR professionally?

---

Need advice on how to handle this without losing the current offer.

Thanks 🙏

reddit.com
u/Cautious_Ad6 — 1 month ago