u/Cerezalacherry

I've always done my makeup like the second picture, but recently I want to do a darker makeup, almost siren like. The problem is i have very rounded and down turned eyes, and when I use the colors I want I feel like they make me look dirty and make my features rough or bigger. Please help, I don't know if my face is just made for cute makeup or if I'm doing anything wrong. I would really like something like grunge eye makeup or a light smokey for everyday, but I really think I look awful with it.