Sandrone Claymore Tierlist
(Weapon order doesn't matter in the columns, for example blackcliff is first but that doesnt mean its the best from this tier)
I made the claymore tierlist basing on what we already know from her kit. I shouldve put Kinich's weapon in "Stat stick" tier but I gave it an honorable mention in a different row because its one of my fav weapons lol.
Tidal Shadow should be the best option for f2p's, though you need a healer and the only viable one might be qiqi but I don't know if her teams will have space for a healer in general 🤔
I wish they'd give us an atk% substat claymore with superconduct buff in the passive from an event instead of claymore skin but oh well.
Tl;dr, you either get her signature weapon or you perish because we have no good 4 star claymores.
EDIT: I forgot about Diona while making the tier list and I got rightfully corrected in the comments - The Unforged should be in the same tier as WGS or slightly below but the difference isn't huge. Originally I put it really low because I couldn't think of any shield characters in her teams that she'd benefit from (again, cuz I forgot about the mondstadt cat)
EDIT 2: Varka's sig becomes a stat stick. I have missed the one word that someone pointed out in the comments - you get the stack when the charged attack begins. Originally I assumed she'd get stack per tick of her charged (Neuvillette-like charged tick) but the animation isn't the one that matters as weapon states. Tbh I wish it worked the way I thought it do lmao
EDIT 3: Serpent spine is also a stat stick, yes. It gives 23% crit rate if I remember correctly, but I placed it as "the basic" weapon because it's really the only good 4 star weapon in general and it's just decent for her and it's better to use it on her than steal idk, Kinich's weapon. Talking stick is a stat stick too, but it's not even worth buying when you can buy Serpent Spine instead as TS is even weaker and while Serpent spine can be used on other characters, talking stick can't, so more people probably have SS in their backpack.