San Gimignano or Val d'Orcia?
Hi all! My husband and I are visiting Tuscany in early October for 3 nights and will have a rental car. I'm deciding between Agriturismo San Marcello (Val d'Orcia) and Agriturismo Il Segreto di Pietrafitta (near San Gimignano).
I love San Marcello, but it doesn't have a restaurant, so we'd need to drive for dinner every night. It also seems to be off the main areas and not as much to do around? Il Segreto offers half board, which is much more convenient and the accomodation looks amazing.
We're hoping to visit Pienza and the thermal baths, so staying in Val d'Orcia makes the most sense. That said, I'm happy to do the extra driving if it means staying at the better accommodation. My main question is: Is the scenery in Val d'Orcia significantly better than around San Gimignano, and worth the trade off of not having a restaurant on site? I'm leaning towards Il Segreto but don't want to miss out if Val d'Orcia is truly a must stay area. Please help!