u/DonSoulwalker

▲ 3 r/Oscars

Who gives the weakest Performance for 2004 Actress?

Vote for #6!!!!!!

Im trying to solidify my personal nominees for Best Actress 2004. Im having a hard time figuring out who should be the runner up? Vote here who you think gives the weakest performance of the line up. Would appreciate the insights.

PS some people argue Kidman should be nominated for Dogville others for Birth so just easier to lump it as one option here.

View Poll

reddit.com
u/DonSoulwalker — 9 hours ago
▲ 1 r/Oscars

Supporting Actor 2025

Question. Ive been trying to fill out my Top 5 best supporting actor personal nominees.

I have

  1. Sean Penn - One Battle After Another

  2. William H. Macy- Train Dreams

I dont have the other 3. My biggest thing is I want to put actual supporting roles. Almost every contender this year was category frauded.

Stellan Skarsgård is Lead, he is the reason Elle Fanning is even in the film

Jacob Elordi, co-lead but 2nd half its entirely his story and he is major component of the first combined woth an hour of screentime

Paul Mescal, Buckley is Lead but he still has over 40% and though hes a little missing from the beginning he helps push the narrative in the beginning and stabilize the ending.

Josh O'Connor Wake Up Dead Man, literally category frauded. Its his story.

David Jonsson, the Long Walk, he and Cooper are the leads within the ensemble

Delroy Lindo? Im sorry hes fine but not really nomination worthy, Jack O Conell is a way stronger performance. Happy Lindo got his career nom after being snubbed for Da 5 Bloods, but hes done much better work.

I really like Alexander Skarsgård in Pillion but I dont even think that had a USA release until this year.

Mark Hamill also exists for Life of Chuck

I could be convinced for Benicio DelToro, even if hes done better work prior.

So without the category fraud of supporting actor who are the 5 you would have in supporting actor this past awards season? Because Im struggling filling it out until 5.

reddit.com
u/DonSoulwalker — 5 days ago