Babymoon: Cheval Blanc St Barths vs Cap Juluca vs Jumby Bay
Looking for advice on which property to choose for a babymoon. I've narrowed it down but would rather hear from people who've actually been to any of these:
Cheval Blanc St Barths
Rosewood Le Guanahani, St Barths
Cap Juluca, Anguilla (have stayed here before but genuinely happy to return)
Jumby Bay Island, Antigua
**Details**
4-5 nights, flexible anytime from mid-November to early December. Flying from NYC.
**What we want:** long beach days and some swimming, great food. We'll probably stay on property most of the time. Want something quiet and peaceful. My husband also likes to run, so bonus points for a good gym or running paths.
**Past resort stays for context:** we've done COMO Parrot Cay before so we're passing on Turks and Caicos. Loved Four Seasons Hualalai and Kona Village next door in Hawaii. Had a great time at The Brando but hated the food. Kokomo Fiji is the best and checks every box, but it's too far to consider again.
**A few specific questions:**
- Has anyone stayed at both Cheval Blanc and Le Guanahani? Any preference?
- How's the travel to any of these destinations? I'll be around 20 to 25 weeks.
- How's the Jumby Bay food given that it's a private island? Is it worth the premium over the other properties if we want to stay just for a few days?
Would love to know if anyone here has been to any of these, or what you'd vote for given the above. Any and all comments appreciated. If you think I'm missing something obvious within about 4–5 hours of NYC, I'm open to it.
Thanks!