u/Existing_Animal_1170

Designing absence-based monitoring for nodes that lose internet for days — how do you build payloads when bandwidth is measured in bytes?

I've been designing a monitoring system for remote nodes that frequently lose internet connectivity. Most solutions I find assume the node can always phone home — but my use case involves locations where the connection is unreliable for days at a time.

My current thinking: instead of relying on presence-based monitoring ("is it reachable?"), design around absence-based monitoring ("has it checked in within the expected window?"). This means the node needs a secondary channel that operates independently of the primary network.

For that secondary channel, I've been evaluating options that work when primary internet is down. Cellular fails in the same dead zones. LoRa needs local infrastructure. The one option I haven't fully explored is satellite IoT — specifically NTN-type modules designed for low-frequency telemetry.

Has anyone built a heartbeat system around one of these? Curious about the data modeling side — how you design payloads when bandwidth is measured in bytes.

reddit.com
u/Existing_Animal_1170 — 2 months ago

Soil sensors + LoRa in an orchard: one hill is killing the link. What's the alternative for terrain-proof telemetry?

I'm building a soil moisture sensor for my dad's orchard — a few STM32 nodes scattered around, battery powered, meant to run for months without attention. I designed the data pipeline around LoRa because the range looked good on paper.

Actual testing has been frustrating. There's a low hill between two of the nodes and the gateway, and the LoRa signal just dies in that gap. I've tried repositioning the gateway twice and it's still a problem.

The data I'm sending is tiny — temperature, moisture, battery voltage, maybe 20 bytes per reading, once every few hours. I'm not looking for high throughput. I just need something reliable that doesn't care about terrain.

Has anyone switched from LoRa to something else for genuinely remote outdoor nodes? What were the tradeoffs?

reddit.com
u/Existing_Animal_1170 — 2 months ago