I keep think Sarah is being set up to turn people against Jade and Tabitha.

We know now that the town kills Jade, and maybe Tabitha too, and the Man in Yellow seems to really enjoy that part. Its not just something that happens, it’s something he looks forward to.

And with Sarah, she’s already been pushed down this road a few times. She keeps getting put in situations where the idea is basically yo do something awful now and it’ll save people later. So I wonder if that’s what he’s preparing her for again.

My guess is he uses her to convince people that Jade and Tabitha are the problem, or that killing them is the only way to stop what’s coming. Sophia might play into it somehow too, especially with all the Bible story stuff going on. Feels like that has to matter.

But I don’t think people would just go along with it unless things get much worse first. So maybe something happens with the talismans, or the nightmares start bleeding into the town more, or there’s some kind of immediate threat that makes everyone panic and want a quick answer?

That’s where I think Boyd comes in. I think he’s one of the things that’s different this time, along with Julie. I don’t think Julie’s role is the same though. To me, she feels more tied to starting the cycle of hope, while Boyd is the one who actually stops them from killing Jade and Tabitha. Maybe he takes their place even and assumes the blame.

The more I re-watch, the less random it all feels. Some thoughts:

What we know:

• The monsters were once human
• A ritual involving children took place to gain immortality
• The children were “born in the dark and killed in the dark”
• They were told a story that gave them hope
• That hope went into the roots of the tree(s)
• A part of the children is still present and saying “remember”
• People are pulled in from different places continuously
• The town feels oddly assembled (mixed eras, objects, layout)
• The ruins connect to deeper layers / the past
• Julie can interact with past events
• Victor survived a previous cycle but remembers very little
• Victor’s drawings hold memories he has forgotten
• Jade and Tabitha are tied to the original event and repeating it
• The goal seems to be: End the cycle, save the children

What we can try to deduce:

The ritual wasn’t just a sacrifice, it was a deal

Humans don’t grant immortality themselves.

So, the ritual likely involved something external, and if it was a deal, both sides get something.

That raises the question: what did the other side get?

I think it's very likely the Townsfolk didn't get exactly what they bargained for.

The children weren’t the cost, they were the mechanism

The ritual needed 7 children for a reason. They weren’t simply killed:

• They are still present in some way
• They are still communicating
• They created the tree system through hope

That suggests they weren’t just sacrificed, but they are part of what keeps everything running.

The place is still running

• People keep getting pulled in
• The environment reacts
• The loop continues
• The trees are moving (Victor was measuring them)

This isn’t static.

It may even be adding to itself from memories, and dream fragments of those trapped and killed each cycle.

It likely feeds on emotion

• Constant fear and suffering
• Characters being pushed to extremes
• The “Lake of Tears” reference

This points to the idea that the system is feeding on: grief, fear, and/or hope. The children were the first source.

The web model (this ties a lot together)

• People and objects get pulled in
• Things accumulate over time
• There are multiple layers (town, ruins, caves, lighthouse)
• Victor draws a spider over what looks like a lake

It behaves like a web: pulling things in, holding them in place, and something at the centre feeding on it.

We know it’s likely connected to the Lake of Tears from one of the drawings. The Lake of Tears feels like more than a metaphor. It sounds like a source/reservoir.

The world is built, not grown

• Buildings from different eras
• No real layout
• Objects out of place

It feels random and eclectic.

Almost like something is building from pieces each cycle. Or from what people bring with them.

A cycle, not just a trap

Loops come up constantly in the story. Not just events repeating, but patterns.

What if the whole thing works like a cycle:

• Something at the centre (the spider?) provides the power
• The children are used to channel it and create the world
• What they create generates fear, grief, and suffering
• That feeds back into the centre

and the cycle continues

“Born in the dark and killed in the dark" might not just be descriptive.

If the children never saw light, never experienced anything outside fear, then they were never meant to have hope at all.

Which means hope wasn’t just absent, it was a threat.

But something changed.

Story is one of the core mechanics

Everything comes back to story:

• The children are given a story; it creates hope
• Ethan understands things through stories
• The Cromenockle mirrors what’s happening
• Clues come through symbols, not direct answers

Truth in this place isn’t given directly, it’s encoded

Julie might be the missing piece

We’re told someone who loved the children told them a story

Julie can enter the past and seemingly interact with it: If you can walk through a story, you go to the beginning.

So, it’s possible she goes back and reads them the Cromenockle.

That would explain:

• why that story matters
• why the world mirrors it

And it creates a loop:

• The system allows Julie to go back
• Julie gives them hope
• That hope helps create the system

Jade and Tabitha didn’t stop it, they got pulled into it

They didn’t stop it.

• They’re tied to the original event
• They keep returning
• Jade asks “why did we do what we did?”

They failed once.

Now they’re stuck repeating it.

They likely need to remember the full story before they can end it properly.

Victor might be the key to breaking it

Victor:

• survived a previous cycle
• documents everything through drawings to avoid remembering fully

His drawings show he must know a lot:

• past events & things no one witnessed
• Key places and figures (spider, trees, lake of tears)

It’s likely that:

• He remembers something that could change the outcome
• He’s choosing not to remember because knowledge has a cost (Victor is deeply disturbed by the message in the barn.)

The Boy in White

He doesn’t feel like part of the system. Hardest to place.

He appears both inside the town and in the real world, and his clothing places him in a specific time. That makes him feel less like something created by the place, and more like something that either arrived later or originates outside it.

• He could be a remnant of a previous cycle, especially if something went differently
• Or something else entirely like a spirit, a fae-like presence, something drawn in by the children’s hope

After Christopher, he changes his approach. He’s more cautious now, which suggests he’s learning from past outcomes.

That adjustment matters.

It makes him feel less like a fixed part of the system and more like something actively trying to influence it and possibly trying to help.

The ruins

The ruins are different than other places and feel important.

That’s where Boyd sees things. That’s where Julie can interact with the past.

Feels like the point where layers overlap. Where the rules loosen.

Maybe even where this started (Ritual site or where the townsfolk discovered the entity?).

Creatures feel like roles within the same system.

Spider: something central that feeds on the web?

Ballerina: affects dreams, possibly controlling imagination (of the children?)

Man in Yellow: enforces behavior or progression, infiltrates

Monsters: harvesting grief and fear

These don’t feel like separate mythologies, they feel like different parts of the same system.

Key Questions

• What was the deal, and with what?
• What are the children being used for now?
• What is the Lake of Tears?
• What does saving the children actually entail?
• What did Jade and Tabitha actually do originally?
• Who has to pay the cost to end it?

Possible ending (Major assumptions)

This doesn’t end with escape. It ends with resolution.

• The children were given a story, perhaps never finished
• The monsters exist without ever facing what they did

To end it:

• The story has to be finished
• The monsters have to remember

But it won’t be free. A sacrifice or impossible choice will be needed.

(Jade, Tabitha, Boyd… someone has to pay for it)

I think there’s still a lot we don’t know, and this could change as more is revealed — but this is what it feels like the show is building toward right now.

TL;DR: The town isn’t random, it’s a system created by the ritual that works more like a web. The children weren’t just sacrificed, they’re being used to sustain it and likely shape everything here, while the system feeds on fear and grief, possibly centred around the Lake of Tears. It hasn’t ended because the story was never finished and the monsters never faced what they did. To break it, the story has to be completed and the truth has to be remembered, but that likely comes with a cost.