Season 5 Critiques
I just finished Season 5 and wanted to share some of my critiques:
“And I think it’s very clear that me trying to fix the restaurant was me trying to fix whatever was happening with my brother” is Carmy’s quote from season 1. Where was Michael in Season 5??? I was genuinely dumbfounded that all we got was an “all good” text from Carmy, and one tiny flashback of Richie with him. Wtf??? They really barely referenced the legit main plot point over the entire show… in the last season?
I really miss the writing from season 1/2. The writing from season 5, as well as most of season 3 and 4, felt like a corny, half-assed comedy/drama. Why do we need all the Fak screentime? That scene with the Faks and Sidney where she’s muttering how he’s a **** under her breath was so stupid and try hard.
Since when did The Bear become a Disney kids show? I swear Season 5 was basically “everyone succeeds, the restaurant is amazing, two Michelin stars, what a happy ending!!!” Like what???
Why did they replace Rob Reiners character with Cheese when they could have just merged his lines with the Computer? I mean why couldn’t the Computer “discover” Ebras plan? There was literally nothing about Cheese’s character where you couldn’t just merge the lines into The Computer.
The guests that just stood there in the kitchen for legitimately two hours was so freaking dumb. What were the writers thinking??? That it would be funny? What kind of serious restaurant would be like “oh yeah, let’s let these random people just take up a bunch of space in our chaotic kitchen on the biggest night of our careers?” It was just so stupid.
The Pete/Sugar hook up scene? Wtf? Felt so out of place and just a real “well this is so forced and so unnecessary”
Overall, I really loved Season 1 and Season 2 of the Bear. I thought there were still some strong points in Season 3 in Carmy’s scenes. But it was really disappointing to watch the show devolve to just dumb, forced comedy jokes with the Faks, and just giving way too much screentime to Sugar’s baby rather than actually focusing on the intriguing parts of the show that made Season 1 and 2 so good. Season 5 was better than 3 or 4, but still overall, just such a decline in writing from the original two seasons.