u/GasObjective3734

Hey guys, could use some help deciding between these two cars.

2014 Corolla S Plus
6-speed manual
114k miles
$9,700
Clean CARFAX, good maintenance history
Transmission fluid + coolant already done
CrossClimate2 tires and recent brakes

2017 Jetta S 1.4T
5-speed manual
Only 36k miles
Trying to get it for around $10.5–11k
Clean CARFAX
Previously VW CPO

I’m in Michigan and drive around 15k miles/year.

I want something comfort, safety and having something enjoyable to drive.

I’m honestly stuck because the Corolla seems like the safe choice, but the Jetta is 3 years newer with almost 78k fewer miles for not much more money.
Which would you guys choose? Would especially appreciate hearing from anyone who’s owned either of these cars long term.