u/Greedy-Purple-7203

Do you have any episodes that you feel are missing an important scene ?

For me I always felt that Season 4's "Showdown in Saskatchewan" needed a scene where Jill confronts Marty about lying to her. Once she finds out, the characters never say a word to each other again.

In season 12's "The Dark Side of the Door", I always wanted a scene where (SPOILER ALERT) the girl finds out that her mother was responsible for her kidnapping. It's a big reveal and would have been a great emotional scene.

I was always disappointed that they never returned to Cabot Cove in any of the TV movies. But if they did, and cared about what the fans wanted, what Cabot Cove citizens would you have liked to have seen return. I know most of us would have loved to have seen Amos and the Beauty Parlor girls. For me, I would also had liked to see Mayor Sam, Bo Dixon and Cornelia from the diner, hunky butcher Tim Mulligan, and the arguing Mercer Hawthorne and Ebeneezer McEnery. Plus Larry Burns and Nils who worked by the docks.

SPOILERS: For me, there are several instances where the show lets characters off a little too easy. Salvatore Gambini in Season 4's "A Very Good Year for Murder". He may have killed a hitman who was endangering his family but he did plan and carry out a murder instead of calling the police. The idea that Jessica wants to let him get away with it (I know he's about to die but still), is so out of character (except When Thieves Fall Out Jessica). Kimberly from Season 6's "Test of Wills", she's suppose to come across as sympathetic but I found her to be too wimpy for me. Yes, she killed by accident but she did try to place the blame first on her grandfather then her aunt, both bad people but still. Finally for me is Eudora in Seasons 5's "Mirror Mirror..." She may not have tried to kill her, but she did drug Jessica and steal and copy her book. At the end she should not be off to visit family but off to jail. Any others ?

What is your longest stretch of favorite episodes that aired after each other ? Mine is in season 2, 8 episodes. It starts with "A Lady in the Lake" and ends with "Keep the Home Fries Burning". I love all those episodes. If it wasn't for "Powder Keg" coming between, it would have been 11 episodes.

Yesterday I was watching the season 8 finale, "Murder on Madison Ave", at one point Jessica lies to a building super to gain access to an apartment, she says she lent the man her large coffee maker and she has the girls coming over for poker. I could swear I've seen this same scene in another episode, but I think it that one she lies to get access to a doctor's office. Am I crazy or does anyone know that episode ?

I was never a fan of the later seasons. Seasons 1-5 are the gold standard for me. I like the Jessica episodes of seasons 6-7 but have no interest in the others. I've grown to really like a lot of season 8 but past that, with few exceptions, I never watch. With episodes live on Roku, I've tried to give them another shot. But aside from some 90's nostalgia, I still don't enjoy them. I figured out the main reason, it's Jessica herself. To me, she loses her warmth. There is a coldness to her interactions with people. I never believe she is close friends with these people. The fact that Grady only comes back once, no Donna or Victoria, no real family really hurts it. Jessica is so stiff, could you imagine Season 11 Jessica pretending to be Emmaline Polsby of Polsby's General Store and Dry Goods in Pullman City, or dancing to the jukebox waiting for Auggie. Even when she's back in Cabot Cove, she doesn't come across like she belongs there. maybe it's just me, lol

Can anyone think of any episodes where they withheld clues from the audience ? The one I always come back to is Season 4's "Deadpan". Jessica figures out the killer >!because he uses the name of the wrong actor in both his TV review and the phony print review.!< But at no time do we hear anyone read that part of the review. Any others ?