Rage Baiting my High Schoolers
I despise the typical first day of school icebreakers. “Two Truths and a Lie” has had its time. I refuse to ask 30 teenagers what animal they’d be and why while we all slowly die inside.
So I’ve been racking my brain for something that might actually break through that painfully awkward first-day silence.
And then it hit me: What if I just piss them off?
My plan is to put students in small groups, give each group a handful of completely inconsequential but rage-inducing statements, and let them argue it out. Nothing political, serious, or actually divisive—just the kind of low-stakes opinions that make teenagers immediately go, “NO. Absolutely not.”
Think:
The toilet paper roll should hang under, not over.
Water is wet.
A hot dog is a sandwich.
Pineapple belongs on pizza.
Cereal is technically soup.
The middle seat gets both armrests.
Crocs are appropriate footwear for every occasion.
The problem is, this activity lives or dies by the quality of the rage bait.
So, Reddit: give me your best harmless opinions/statements that would have a room full of high schoolers passionately arguing within 30 seconds.
I want petty. I want ridiculous. I want hills they are inexplicably willing to die on.
(For reference I teach 9-12 but mostly 10th grade science)