u/Imaginary-Avocado-

Bought one of each to see which I prefer. Zero Sugar is ok, but tastes a little flat at the end. Diet Mountain Lightning has effervescent citrus flavor, better carbonation, and is the clear winner. Looking at labels, it might get the edge because of the small amount of real juice?

Anyone drink Mountain Lightning? The Diet is very, very close to the real thing. I could see it replacing Dew for me, except for the flavors Dew offers.

I'm a zero sugar soda drinker but curiosity got the best of me. It's got nice cherry flavor and is sour but not overpowering. After trying it, I put it in the freezer to get it extra cold and ended up with a little ice in it, which was fine because it tastes like a sour cherry icee.

8.5/10 but wouldn't revisit because of the sugar

I've enjoyed both of these over the years, so I put them head to head to see if there was a clear winner to keep buying. Crush is it for me. It tastes more complex, like a real orange.

Thoughts on Crush vs Sunkist? What's your favorite orange soda?

The Dirty Dew has that lemon cream flavor, so I tried adding lime juice but it didn't hit right. Adding Baja Blast, though, you get key lime pie. Going to do this to get through my 12 Dirty Dew a lot tastier.

Anyone else try this combo?

Bought these as a taste test to see if either could replace my Diet Pepsi/Coke Zero fix. They were both ok to me, with the zero being slightly better. Anyone else tried these generic diet colas?