u/ImmediatePut8282

I’m trying to decide on my first gravel bike and could use some advice. I don’t have a firm budget, but I’d rather stay around or under $2k CAD if possible. I’m mainly looking for good value, not necessarily the fanciest bike.

I’ve never owned a modern bike — my last bike was a basic $500 setup — so I feel like some of the higher-end features might be lost on me. That said, I still want something reliable that can comfortably handle commuting, weekend adventures, gravel paths, and the occasional longer road ride (100 km+).

Here are the options I’m considering:

1. 2020 Marin Headlands 1 — $2,000 CAD ($1460 USD) from marketplace
   Pros:
   - Comes with both road and gravel wheel/tire setups
   - Includes the option to come with flat or clip pedals
   - Seems like a solid spec for the money
   Cons:
   - 6 year old, well used carbon bike

2. 2025 Giant Revolt 1 — $2000 CAD ($1460 USD) new from LBS
   Pros:
   - Brand new from a reputable local shop
   - Warranty/support
   - Modern geometry and components
   Cons:
   - Only comes with one tire setup
   - Need to buy pedals separately

3. Something cheaper/new like a Marin Gestalt or MEC Provincial - $14-1600 CAD ($10-1400 USD)
   Pros:
   - Lower cost
   - Brand new
   Cons:
   - Lower-spec components
   - Might outgrow it quickly?

4. Something else entirely that I haven’t considered yet

For context:
- Riding would mostly be commuting, fitness, long mixed-surface rides, and general exploring
- Reliability matters more to me than racing performance
- I’d rather buy once and be happy than constantly upgrade

What would you do in my position?

TLDR: looking to buy first gravel bike, considering used higher spec, new middle spec or something I haven’t looked into. Thanks