Cat on a Hot Tin Roof and the three actresses vying for the role of Maggie
Drama, jealousy, and betrayal aside—from the little we saw—the three actresses vying for the role of Maggie were all excellent in their own ways (it’s a shame we didn’t get to see the other two selected girls perform).
Within the story, I find it logical and fitting that Brenda lands the role; she perfectly embodies that kind of desperate allure and passionate loneliness that define Maggie. She really is the "cat on a hot tin roof."
But her two competitors were very good in their own styles, too.
Kelly offered a more emotional, fragile Maggie. Even a bit maternal—an interesting take on her relationship with Brick.
Laura held her own, too. Her take was vibrant and glamorous, yet teetering on the edge of madness—also very interesting.
In short:
- Brenda: the obvious, safe choice; she’s practically the archetype of Maggie.
- Laura: similar to Brenda’s approach, but a Maggie who is less internalized and closer to the brink of madness.
- Kelly: the least obvious choice—a softer, more subdued version of Maggie—which is also interesting.
Anyway, as you can tell: this is my favorite storyline in all of 90210 ^^