There was a Wawa at 1801 Newport Rd in Croydon, PA. The before pic is from August 2007 and the next one is August 2013 and it was a Pantry 1. No other info, and no property record so it was probably a rental. That freakishly large parking lot must have been a nightmare to keep clean
This one is completely from my own memory! Back in the early 90's a friend of mine ran this store, and it had an old Gulf branded gas pump in the front. IIRC, Wawa had to take the gas to get the lease on the store. The second pic is the current Google Earth image and the third is when it still had the gas canopy in front, no tower, and the Wawa signature peak by the front door.
Almost completely obscured by shrubbery, there was a Wawa at 27 N Maple Ave in Marlton, NJ. Looking at google street view, it was a Wawa August 2013, and by October 2015 the spot was vacant. A bit down the road is a Super Wawa which google tells me opened June 2015, so that's probably when the legacy store closed.
There was a Wawa at 76 Springside Rd in Westampton Township, NJ. Looks like the store closed July 2019, it was a pile of rubble August 2019, and the grand re-opening was spring 2020.
There was a Wawa at 99 S John F Kennedy Way in Willingboro, NJ. The property sold April 18 2001
There was a Wawa at 300 Charleston Rd in Willingboro, NJ. Originally bought in 1982, the property sold on July 29 1997. There are three Super Wawas in the vicinity but it doesn't look like any of them opened in that time frame.
There was a Wawa at 4159 US-130 in Beverly, NJ. The property sold in September 2003, and there is a Super Wawa right next door that dates from about the same time.
There was a Wawa at 53-63 Mill St, in Mt Holly, NJ. The property sold December 17 1999, and was purchased from ARCO in 1984.
There was a Wawa at 1680 NJ-38 in Mt Holly, NJ, and according to Burlington County, Wawa sold the property on July 18 2005, so I assume the store closed in the first half of 2005.
There was a Wawa (and a liquor store) at the intersection of South Pemberton rd and Vincentown - Columbus Rd in Southampton Township, NJ. Looking at Google Earth and street view, the Wawa side was demolished and rebuilt as a Super Wawa between December 2010 and its grand opening January 8 2012. By May 2019, the liquor store was also demo'd and replaced with landscape.
There was a Wawa at 210 Wrightstown Georgetown Rd in Chesterfield, NJ. The store closed and was demolished sometime between May 2020 and and April 2021 (according to Google Earth) and had its grand re-opening in February 2022
There was a Wawa at 1502 Liberty St in Trenton, NJ. The property sold May 2009. Like the other Trenton area stores, they packed up and left without a nearby replacement. The second store (third image) is 2013 Hamilton Ave, Trenton, NJ 08619 and I have no sales info on that, someone else owned the land, and it was probably rented to Wawa.
There was a Wawa at 280 NJ-31 in Hopewell Township, NJ. The property sold August 2003, and I'm guessing based on Google Earth that the store was immediately demolished and re-built as a bank. The nearest Wawa is about 10 miles away!
There was a Wawa at 901 S Broad St in Trenton, NJ. The property sold in November 1999, so we're assuming it closed somewhere prior to then. There are no larger stores nearby (IE Super Wawa), so there is no obvious reason why it closed.
There was a Wawa at 1719 Greenwood Ave in Trenton, NJ. The property sold in December 1997, and I assume the store closed sometime late 1997. Another boring one!
There was a Wawa at 3001 E State St in Trenton, NJ. Mercer County says the property sold January 1998, so I assume the store closed in 1997
There was a Wawa at 1186 Fischer Blvd in Toms River, NJ. The property sold March 13 2002. There are two Super Wawa's about a mile north and 1/4 mile south that have been there before 12/2002 (according to Google Earth)
There was a Wawa at 10 6 Lanes Mill Rd in Brick Township, NJ. (Burnt Tavern Road) It closed December 2021, was demolished, and a new Super Wawa replaced it, which opened April 6 2023.
https://nj1015.com/popular-jersey-shore-wawa-for-commuters-and-visitors-in-brick-has-closed/
https://patch.com/new-jersey/brick/wawa-announces-grand-opening-new-brick-store
Behind a row of trees blocking the view is a Lucky 7 deli which is in the spot where there was a Wawa on 408 NJ-70 in Lakehurst, NJ. according to Google street view, sometime between July 2011 and September 2013, it changed hands. There's a Super Wawa 1/4 mile away, which opened over a decade later on July 20 2023.
There was a Wawa at 1201 NJ-70 in Manchester Township, NJ. Although the property sold February 18, 2008, there is a Super Wawa kitty-corner across the intersection that opened well before that. Google Earth from August 2006 shows the completed Super with cars in the parking lot, so no idea when the legacy store closed or the Super Wawa actually opened.