u/KMETsteele

Any tips for how to set this model up properly in 1D - steady flow? (beginner)
▲ 6 r/HECRAS

Any tips for how to set this model up properly in 1D - steady flow? (beginner)

https://preview.redd.it/rhdftwqax0kh1.png?width=1532&format=png&auto=webp&s=2e39213cb9ee0fbef99cca203ac03ddebccfd1e7

Modeling a proposed canal (left) that ties to an existing channel (right) with a culvert. I'm running into WSE backwatering issues which I believe have something to do with the following error warning I received for the XS immediately downstream of the junction.

  • The energy equation could not be balanced within the specified number of iterations. The program used critical depth for the water surface and continued on with the calculations.

I have tried many tips and tricks for improving model stability like reducing XS spacing, making sure XS are as close to the junction as possible, cleaning up manning's n values, and increasing maximum iterations/tolerances for the steady flow analysis. I've looked into modeling the culvert as an inline structure and a lateral structure, but haven't yielded any good results. I also tried using a terrain modification to allow for cleaner XS along the existing channel.

How would you model this configuration? Or is a 1D-steady model too limited for a junction like this?

u/KMETsteele — 3 days ago

What do y’all think?

I know I’m probably gonna get roasted, but how bad is it really?

u/KMETsteele — 2 months ago