FMC overhears she was second choice or a mistake, aka similar to {Dutch and Penelope by GroveltoHEA}
I read {Dutch and Penelope by GroveltoHEA} a few days ago and I really liked the premise but it was too short for me and now I‘m looking for something similar.
It‘s about the FMC who overhears the MMC talking with an ex hook up who he actually wanted to ask out but it was a misunderstanding at the time and he asked the FMC and he didn‘t want to hurt her feelings and went to the date and then immediately fell in love with her and everything was real between them but she overhears that and now thinks it was all a mistake.
So now I‘m looking for a book where FMC overhears that she was kind of a second choice or no choice at all and questions everything that happened between them, while the MMC actually really loves her and it was all real for him and he has to show her that.
Bonus points if the FMC is not conventionally attractive and is insecure but MMC loves everything about her.
Hard no‘s: cheating, love triangle, poly, OWD is okay but I want it only one sided from the OW and not the MMC, grief or death of loved ones or animals
Thanks in advance!