u/LegGroundbreaking960

Image 1 — Old house plumbing question: sink P-trap located below floor
Image 2 — Old house plumbing question: sink P-trap located below floor

Old house plumbing question: sink P-trap located below floor

Bought an 1880s house a few years ago and discovered one of its quirks: the bathroom sink P-trap is not under the sink. The drain goes straight through the vanity/floor, and the actual P-trap is located in the basement below the bathroom floor.

This setup has worked fine until recently. The sink now drains extremely slowly/almost not at all, and we’ve tried all the normal DIY fixes:
- plunger
- drain cleaner
- hand snake from above
- removing/cleaning the stopper
Nothing has worked.

We’re calling a plumber, but I wanted some opinions from pros first.

A contractor previously told us that relocating the trap under the sink (where it would normally be) would be a “massive job” and quoted around $10k.
We’re planning to replace the bathroom vanity soon anyway, so I’m wondering:

Q: Is moving the P-trap into the vanity actually a major project in an old house like this?

Q: Is there any reason this setup needs to stay the way it is?

Q: Does the current configuration suggest venting issues or other likely problems?

Photos attached:

  1. current under-sink setup
  2. basement view showing the trap below the floor

Appreciate any insight from people who deal with old-house plumbing regularly.

u/LegGroundbreaking960 — 4 days ago