I didn't really like TLOU2.
I know this might get downvoted into oblivion, but I just finished Part 2 and I need to get this off my chest.
The first game is a masterpiece for me—tight pacing, incredible chemistry between Joel and Ellie, and a story that balanced hope and despair perfectly. Part 2, on the other hand, felt like a slog in places.
Here’s why I think it’s worse:
Pacing issues – The switch to Abby right at the climax of the theater sequence killed all momentum for me. I understand what they were going for, but playing as Abby for 10+ hours after that cliffhanger was frustrating.
Overstretched length – The first game was lean and focused. Part 2 feels bloated, with repetitive “clear the room” encounters and flashbacks that could have been trimmed.
Ellie’s arc – I appreciate a dark revenge story, but by the end, it felt like misery for misery’s sake. The final fight on the beach left me empty, not in a profound way, just exhausted.
Joel’s death – Not that he died, but how it was handled. It felt rushed and disrespectful to a character we spent an entire game bonding with. The flashbacks helped, but too little, too late.
That said, the gameplay is smoother, the visuals are stunning, and the performances are top-notch. I just don’t think the story holds a candle to the original.
Am I alone here? I’m not saying it’s a bad game—just a massive disappointment compared to TLOU1. Let me know your thoughts (but please keep it civil).