
Quick Comparison - Aluminum v. Zinc for decorative casting
(This is AKA "How I learned to stop melting cans and love Zinc)
On the left you have Zinc - On the right you have aluminum
Both cast into two sided graphite molds from Timeless Foundry (love their stuff!)
Left was Zinc, poured in, then popped out.
Right was Aluminum, Pre-heated the molds to try to help flow, and still had surface tension issues. (You can tell as it doesn't pick up those details NEAR as well as the zinc). The best I've gotten from aluminum is partially overcoming that surface tension by adding ground up Potassium Chloride as a fluxing agent (seems to help "fluidity").
All coins were then given 24 hours in a vibrating tumbler with Walnut shells and brasso to clean them up/polish.
Overall, Zinc produces a MUCH better natural finish, has a heftier feel to them, and takes around half or less the propane to melt. I used to only do zinc/die cast when I had a bunch piling up, but now that I've learned to control the temp better it's become my favorite "Cheap white metal" (Silver will always hold the title for white metals when cost isn't a concern)