u/NextSubject227

feel like CodeRabbit has gone too far in the direction of commenting on everything it possibly can.

on bigger PRs especially, you can end up with a wall of review comments where a few are genuinely useful but a lot are things i'd never block a PR over.

and at some point that makes the good comments less useful too. if engineers get used to dismissing half the bot's comments, they're eventually going to skim the one that actually matters.

saw Theo mention macroscope recently so gave it a try and it seems much better on noise. BugBot too.

at this point i don't really care which reviewer leaves the most comments. i just want the comments it does leave to actually matter.

when does an AI reviewer become too noisy for you?