u/No_Gold3131

Thank you all for the interesting discussions the past few days. I think the anniversary of this terrible crime has many of us thinking, and several people brought up points I had never considered before. It's a testament to how confusing this case remains.

I've said it several times, and I'll repeat it. Anything is possible with regard to this case. I wouldn't be surprised to find out the perpetrator was someone completely off the radar; that is, if we ever get any resolution at all.

With all that said, here is my ranking of current theories of who was responsible from most likely to least.

1. One or more of the grave robbers, plus an additional, unknown perpetrator (s).
2. Associate of grave robbers, with no direct involvement of the three grave robbers.
3. Relative/Friend/lover/associate of Sherrill's, who had a beef with her for some reason.
4. Relative/Friend/boyfriend/associate of Susie
5. Stalker of Susie and/or Sherrill
6. Relative/Stalker/boyfriend/former boyfriend of Stacy
7. Someone, or someones, from the graduation parties, arising from a recent altercation
8. Contractor/worker related to the recent move into the Delmar residence
9. Neighborhood peeping Tom
10. Someone unknown living in the neighborhood
11. Random perpetrator, possible serial killer, perhaps spotted them on the way home
12. High school friend group

I think of Bartt Streeter and the McCall family, who have lived so long without answers. I would like to know where the remains are for the sake of those families.

However, I suspect the remains are on private property, and finding them would lead directly to the perpetrator. That is why they have never been revealed.