A Trending Issue on TikTok
OK. So, my feelings about bringing things across platforms is that I generally try to avoid it (unless it's a video that illustrates a point or a technique that's useful.) But there's something I've been seeing on TikTok that I think we should discuss here.
Apparently, someone (I'm not sure who, I've been looking for the original video and can't seem to find it) commented that "It's ableist to use big words in writing." The response to this has been overwhelmingly negative, and for the most part rightly so. The idea that people with cognitive challenges will feel diminished when they encounter a big word in print assumes that such people haven't developed strategies for this very situation.
People who have cognitive issues, learning disabilities, etc. have been taught how to deal with their limitations in constructive, proactive ways. Then they encounter things they don't recognize or don't understand, they don't curl up into a tiny ball and weep bitterly; they use the strategies they've developed to overcome that problem or side-step it.
Also, when a professionally trained writer goes to writing school to get a BFA or an MFA, they are taught to avoid using large words unless they are absolutely necessary. "Know your target audience" is a critical concept every writer wants to learn and master. If you're writing genre fiction, the general rule is to write around a 7th grade reading level.
Seriously.
Most best sellers are written at a 7th grade reading level. Stephen King writes so that 6th graders can read his works.
Again, for those in the back:
The target goal of a writer is for their work to be readable by someone who reads at a 7th grade reading level.
But that's genre fiction and some people like literary fiction. What about that level?
Most of the classic literary works of the 20th century are actually written at a 5th to 6th grade reading level.
Contemporary literary fiction goes up to about the 9th grade reading level.
What makes literature good isn't the size of the words, it's how well the author uses them. Kinda of like...nevermind. :D
What makes literature good isn't the language used, it's how it's used to describe setting, show characters' motivations, and move the plot.
I can see a reason for using big words in literature, and it's not to be witty or clever. Big words shoved into the mouth of a single character makes them less relatable, less sympathetic, more pedantic, and less likable to the reader.
Consider:
"Your efforts to obfuscate what was undertaken in your crapulent state a fortnight ago shall not assoil you," the constable barked. "We have discerned you inveigled your neighbor to betray his adjuration and then sought to assuage the misdeed by profferring anodynes! Villainy!"
Who wants to punch that guy in the face?