
Oklahoma couple sues Insurance Commissioner over unreleased State Farm investigation
There’s a new development in the ongoing fight over State Farm roof claims in Oklahoma.
Craig and Elizabeth Gutierrez have filed a lawsuit against Oklahoma Insurance Commissioner Glen Mulready, asking a judge to force the release of the state’s two-year investigation into State Farm’s handling of roof claims.
Mulready said last year that the report would be released by March 31, 2026. It still hasn’t been made public.
The new petition goes further, alleging Mulready delayed regulatory action until after the August runoff election and accusing him of withholding the report for political reasons.
The Gutierrez family has been battling State Farm over a roof damaged during a 2024 hailstorm in northwest OKC. Their attorneys say they represent hundreds of Oklahoma State Farm policyholders with denied or underpaid roof claims.
Important distinction: this new lawsuit is against Mulready, not State Farm. The goal is to make the Insurance Department release what its investigation found.
Whatever your view of State Farm or the commissioner, Oklahoma policyholders deserve to know:
What did the two-year investigation find, and why hasn’t the report been released?