u/Ok-Risk-5723

I am currently reading Hemingways Short stories and some accompanying secondary sources.

while reading up on up in Michigan I discovered that there is a debate on wether the story can be seen as rape or not.

One side argues that it is rape because the woman said no several times while the other side argues that it’s not because she clearly wanted it.
Whats your opinion? Any other views on this or do you think it’s about something else entirely?