u/Ok_Serve_6632

We know, that there is a set number of people in the Fromville. When 1 dies, 1 come, if more then 1 comes, 1 has to die. But I was wondering now. Jim died, the priest should've come, he picked up Sophia and later Sophia(MiY) killed him.

So based on that rule, new guy should've come right? MiY is not part of the townfolk, or at least it makes no sense to me that he would be the +1.

Do you agree or am I missing something? Maybe the tooth could be a reason why new guy didn't show up? Like if he takes the teeth, he is still considered "in town" or something?