
Fast Food Review Day 256 - The Meats Pizza from Papa John's
| Chain Name | Papa John's Pizza |
|---|---|
| Food category | Primary: Pizza...allegedly |
| # of US Locations | 3146 |
| # of US States | 49 |
| Primarily located in | Everywhere except Vermont |
| Restaurant Rank in US $ Sales 2024 | 31st (out of 500) |
| Restaurant Rank in US $ Sales 2025 | 31st (out of 500) |
| Rank of price (high to low) (Average: $16.34, standard dev. $3.03) | 241st out of 295 meal reviews |
| Quality / Value Rating for this specific meal | 2.5 (out of 10) / 6 (out of 10) |
Hey, it's Review Day #100,000,000 in Binary! Whoo!
And on this day, in the immortal words of the legendary fast food reviewer ReviewBrah, "My disappointment was immeasurable and my day was ruined."
Oh, Papa John's, how far have you fallen! It wasn't that long ago in the past, that you were running on the slogan, "Better Ingredients, Better Pizza", and growing like crazy. As the fourth chain in the "Big Four" of pizza restaurants, the sky was the limit, or so it seemed.
But in the past five years, Papa John's stock has tumbled 70%. Stores are experience year-over-year lower sales...again, while there are corporate layoffs and C-suite turnover. Right now, they are planning a 'strategic repositioning' by closing hundreds of low-performing stores over the next year.
How did it reach this point? Well, all one needs to do is take a single bite of their pizzas...and you'll know. I ordered their version of the all-meat pizza, and it was just a Visit To Frown-Town all around. They had meats, alright, but almost entirely tasteless. You could FEEL the texture of the meat, but the flavor was just not there. The sauce was light and bland, the dough was unremarkable. And worst of all, that cheese! It was like I was eating a plastic pizza. Ugh, it didn't taste like cheese, and it didn't behave like cheese on the pizza, either. I don't know what that substance was.
Better ingredients, my ass. This sucked.
All the news for Papa John's is bad news these days, it seems, with no glimmers of improvement in sight (as opposed to, say, KFC, which is also a massively struggling chain but they have announced a massive, detailed plan to completely change over the next few years). Papa John's is facing a tough market where consumer preferences towards pizzas are changing, and Domino's is eating their proverbial lunch right now.
In fact, Papa John's is on a path that could lead it to fall out of the coveted 'Big Four' pizza chain status. Marco's in a distant fifth place, is trying, but they have a long way to go -- instead you have to look outside of the pizza restaurant business for the REAL fifth place pizza chain: Casey's. Approaching two thousand stores, the Casey's World Empire rolls on, slinging pizzas wherever they go and grow. In fact, I was shocked to discover they even have brand new built-from-the-ground-up stores in Marble Falls and Burnet, of all places - and have also grown by merger with CEFCO stores being rebranded as we speak. At the rate they're growing, they could surpass Papa John's as the fourth largest pizza producer in a matter of a couple of years.
Papa John's better get its act together quick. But until then, avoid avoid avoid. Terrible tasting pizza. The only saving grace is that it was one of the cheapest priced off-the-menu pizzas out there, but that means nothing to me if saving a few bucks means eating shit.
----
(About this review series: Starting in late 2025, I am visiting a different fast food/fast casual chain every day, until I run out of places to visit. Aiming to review as many chains on the Technomics Top 500 Restaurants list as possible, plus key/important regional and some local chains as well. UPDATE - I will be wrapping up this review series with Day #365. And no, I haven't gained weight, and no, it hasn't hurt my health.)