Hey Noah closed out #1 Product of the Week on PH. Here’s what actually happened.
▲ 5 r/ProductHuntLaunches+1 crossposts

Hey Noah closed out #1 Product of the Week on PH. Here’s what actually happened.

Hey all, founder of Hey Noah here.

We launched last Tuesday and ended the week as #1 Product of the Week on Product Hunt.

Before launching, I read probably too many posts about how to do Product Hunt properly. Most of them had a very clean playbook: "do X before launch, Y on launch day, Z after, and here are the results."

Ours didn’t really feel like that.

For some context, Noah handles scheduling over text, email, and WhatsApp. Instead of opening another app, you just tell it something like “find time with Sarah next week,” and it handles the back-and-forth.

Going into the launch, I assumed we’d spend most of the day explaining that. We didn’t. People immediately started trying to find the edges.

>What happens if someone reschedules?
What if there are three time zones involved?
What happens when Noah gets something wrong?
When does it ask me before doing something, and

When does it just go ahead and handle it?

That last question stuck with me.

We’ve spent a lot of time thinking about whether Noah can reliably do the work. But the people trying it were asking a slightly different question: how much control am I comfortable handing over?

It sounds obvious in hindsight, but that ended up being one of the more useful things we learned from the launch. The interesting problem isn’t just getting an AI to schedule correctly. It’s knowing when it should act and when it should come back to you.

The other thing people kept bringing up was that there’s no Hey Noah app. It works through SMS/iMessage, WhatsApp, and email. Some people initially assumed we just hadn’t built the app yet. But removing another app you have to open and check is pretty much the whole idea.

Anyway, #1 Product of the Week was great, but getting a few hundred people poking at the product and asking questions we hadn’t anticipated was probably the more useful part.

There were things that worked, things that absolutely didn’t, and a few things we’d do differently if we launched again.

u/Remarkable-Pair8389 — 9 days ago

We built an AI executive assistant that works over email and text. We're trending #1 on Product Hunt today.

I'm one of the people behind Noah.

The problem we kept hitting: scheduling and follow-ups eat hours every week. Most tools fix this by adding another dashboard to check. That never stuck for us.

So Noah has no app. You CC it on an email or text it like a person.

What it does:

  • Schedules meetings. Handles the back and forth, time zones, and the invite.
  • Sends post-meeting notes, action items, and follow-ups.
  • Briefs you before a call on who you're meeting and your last interaction.

We launched on Product Hunt this morning and are trending #1.

Happy to answer anything about how it works, what it gets wrong, or how we built it. Link in comments since I don't want this to read as pure promo.

u/Remarkable-Pair8389 — 16 days ago

The best calendar system I have seen does three jobs, not one.

Most calendar advice focuses on arranging time. That is the easiest layer.

After years of watching strong executive assistants work, I think a useful calendar system has three jobs:

  1. Protect time: Not every open block is available. Thinking time, recovery time, and work that only you can do must survive other people's urgency.
  2. Create context: A meeting title is not a briefing. You need to know who is attending, what happened last time, why the meeting matters, and what decision is expected.
  3. Hold accountability: A meeting without captured promises creates another meeting. Someone must know what was agreed, who owns the next step, and when it comes back.

The calendar is only the visible surface. Underneath it sit priorities, relationships, and commitments.

That is why a perfectly organized week can still feel chaotic. The blocks may fit, but the context does not travel with them.

Before adding another productivity app, inspect which of these three layers is actually failing.

Which one creates the most friction in your week: protection, context, or accountability?

reddit.com
u/Remarkable-Pair8389 — 1 month ago

We were getting covered by CNN and The Wall Street Journal. We were also barely making rent.

For a while, at my old company that I founded - YML, people in Silicon Valley knew us as the app guys.

Our consumer apps reached the charts. CNN and The Wall Street Journal covered the work. From the outside, this looked like momentum.

Our bank account told a different story.

We were not making money sustainably. I was married and on a visa. Friends with jobs at Google and Facebook were buying homes while we were still trying to make rent.

Press was giving us a dangerous kind of comfort. It confirmed that people noticed the work, but it did not prove that we had a business.

The signal we eventually followed was less glamorous: large companies kept asking us for help. Safeway, Salesforce, SAP, and others had web teams but lacked mobile expertise. They had a real problem and a budget attached to it.

So we stopped protecting our identity as product founders and pivoted toward customer demand. Helping companies become mobile-first built the business that our celebrated consumer apps never did.

Attention can tell you that a story travels. Revenue tells you that a problem matters enough to solve repeatedly.

What vanity metric fooled you for longer than it should have?

reddit.com
u/Remarkable-Pair8389 — 1 month ago
▲ 16 r/ExperiencedFounders+1 crossposts

I spent 14 years building without VC money. In Silicon Valley, people assumed something was wrong with me.

For years, the easiest way to make a conversation awkward in Silicon Valley was to tell someone we were bootstrapped.

Fundraising had become a badge of honor. Friends were joining Google and Facebook, buying houses, and building financial security. I was married, on a visa, and spending years with a bank balance that stayed stubbornly small.

Meanwhile, our apps were getting attention from CNN and The Wall Street Journal. From the outside, we looked successful. Inside the company, we were still trying to build sustainable revenue.

Not raising money forced a useful kind of honesty. We could not keep funding ideas because they sounded exciting. We had to follow what customers were willing to pay for.

That is why we eventually stopped chasing consumer-app fame and helped established companies become mobile-first. It was not the fashionable choice. It became the business.

Bootstrapping also let us make that pivot on our own timeline. Years later, when we sold 60% of the company, we could negotiate from a position we had built rather than one dictated by a financing clock.

I do not think bootstrapping is morally superior. It simply trained us to separate attention from demand.

Founders who bootstrapped, what did people assume about you that turned out to be wrong?

reddit.com
u/Remarkable-Pair8389 — 1 month ago

Day One AI : Private Dinner Series for AI Product Builders - Dinner #01 (Founder/CTO Edition)

Everyone can make an AI demo work now. That's table stakes.

What separates a demo from a product customers actually depend on:

  1. Reliability engineering - not prompt engineering
  2. Evals that predict user trust - not benchmarks on papers
  3. Architecture decisions - deterministic guardrails, modular agents, confidence thresholds
  4. Painful honesty - what did you try that failed? What would you never let an LLM do directly?

Starting Day One AI, a series of private dinners for founder/CTOs building AI in production. Dinner #01 brings together 8 people working on these exact problems. Off the record. No panels.

If you're dealing with these challenges in production register using the link in the comment.

reddit.com
u/Remarkable-Pair8389 — 3 months ago

We launched Hey Noah 90 days ago. Here are the real numbers, what broke, and what we're changing.

It's been 90 days since launch. Building in the AI agent space is a total pivot from the service-based world of YML. We have over 5,000 signups on the waitlist. The biggest surprise is how many users interact almost exclusively via Voice while driving. We are accidentally becoming the "Car Assistant."

But things broke. In the first two weeks, the scheduling back-and-forth was too slow. If an AI takes 10 seconds to respond, an executive has already moved on. Time zone math across four different platforms is also a nightmare.

We realized users don't want a chat bot. They want a shadow. We're moving more resources into proactive features so Noah tells you what you missed instead of waiting for you to ask. For other SaaS founders, what was the biggest gap between your v1 vision and real-world usage?

reddit.com
u/Remarkable-Pair8389 — 3 months ago
▲ 3 r/siliconvalley+1 crossposts

An EA professional helped me design Hey Noah's workflows. Here's what she said we got wrong.

I’m a software founder. I like logic and clean lines, but when I started building Hey Noah, I realized logic wasn't enough. I spent weeks sitting with professional EAs because I needed to know what invisible work a computer usually misses.

We thought scheduling was just about finding an empty slot. An EA taught us it’s about momentum. You don't put a high-stakes board call after a 3-hour internal debate, and you don't schedule a strategy session at 4 PM on a Friday. A computer sees free time, but a human sees exhaustion.

What we did get right was living in SMS and Voice. Executives are mobile. They don't want another app to manage while they are in airports or cars. They want a shadow they can talk to. I’ve built apps for Apple and PayPal, but building an AI to replicate the judgment of a great EA is the hardest thing I’ve ever done.

What’s a momentum or context rule you use that no software currently understands?

reddit.com
u/Remarkable-Pair8389 — 3 months ago

I bootstrapped a $100M company. Here are the delegation mistakes I made in year 1 that cost me heavily in year 5.

Scaling YML to $100M+ revenue without VC funding meant every mistake came directly out of my own pocket. Delegation was the hardest lesson to learn.

My first mistake was delegating tasks instead of outcomes. I used to tell people to send an email, when I should have told them to make sure the client felt prioritized. I also had a massive hero complex. I assumed doing it myself was faster, and it was until we hit 50 people and I became the bottleneck that almost killed the company.

When I finally hired an EA, I didn't give her a framework for how I think. I expected her to read my mind, which is a setup for failure. I was also embarrassed by my inbox and tried to hide my disorganization. Your assistant needs to see the mess to fix it. If you hire someone, let them see how bad it is.

Which of these are you currently struggling with as you scale?

reddit.com
u/Remarkable-Pair8389 — 3 months ago

I tracked every minute of my calendar for 90 days. Here's what was actually stealing executive time.

Most founders assume their time is eaten up by massive projects or endless client calls. When I audited my calendar while building my new startup, I found that "administrative drift" was quietly consuming 22% of my week.

The biggest culprit was the scheduling loop, the constant back-and-forth of finding a time that works. It isn't just the typing, it's the context switching that kills your focus. Another massive sink was the context gap. I was spending the first 8 minutes of every meeting figuring out who the person was and what we promised them last month. Add in the follow-up chase of sending notes and confirming next steps, and it added up quickly.

For a 50-hour work week, that's 11 hours of low-value labor. If your time is worth $500/hr, you're lighting $5,500 on fire every week.

What’s the biggest invisible time sink in your current workflow?

reddit.com
u/Remarkable-Pair8389 — 3 months ago

Human EA vs AI assistant: I've used both for 14 years. Here's what AI still can't do.

As someone who relied on a human EA to build a $100M company and is now building an AI EA (Hey Noah), I have a clear view of where the tech actually fails.

AI is incredibly fast and never forgets a preference. It will remember that I only take Zoom calls after 2 PM on Tuesdays, and it's there on a Saturday night when I'm stressing about next week's travel.

But humans win on judgment and relationships. A human knows why a certain meeting shouldn't happen because they understand the office politics. A human EA builds rapport with your partners, whereas AI is strictly transactional. If a flight is canceled and there are no easy options, a human will find a creative workaround that an LLM can't see.

My goal with Hey Noah is to give every founder the 80% leverage a human EA provides at a fraction of the cost, but the human edge is still real.

What’s the one task you think AI will never be able to replicate for an executive?

reddit.com
u/Remarkable-Pair8389 — 3 months ago
▲ 9 r/ExperiencedFounders+1 crossposts

I got an email from Steve Jobs in 2009. It gave me the courage to quit my job and go all in on Y Media Labs.

Over the next 14 years, we scaled YML to a $100M+ exit. But as the company grew, the actual work of building products was buried under a mountain of administration. I was spending half my day on scheduling, follow-ups, and briefings.

I only survived because my EA kept the calendar from killing my creativity. She built the context that allowed me to lead. When I exited YML, I realized that 99% of founders don't have a $10k/month budget for a world-class human partner, so they stay stuck in the admin trap.

That’s why I'm building an AI Executive Assistant. I wanted to take the logic my EA used the context management, the proactive scheduling, the relationship memory and build it into an AI that lives in SMS and Emails. Executives don't need another dashboard; they need leverage.

[Disclosure: I am the founder. I’m NOT here to pitch, but to share how we’re trying to solve the problem of founder leverage.]

If you could automate the 3 hours a day you spend on administrative overhead, what would you do with that time?

reddit.com
u/Remarkable-Pair8389 — 3 months ago

The 3-category system my EA used to run my calendar so I could actually do my job.

I used to treat my calendar like a game of Tetris. If there was a white space, I’d fill it. If someone asked for 15 minutes, I’d give it. I was working 80 hours a week and achieving almost nothing.

My EA, Danira, stopped the madness. She forced me to categorize every single entry into one of three buckets.

1 Protection Layer: We blocked 4 hours a week for nothing but strategy. If a client wanted that time, the answer was no.

  1. Context Layer: I used to walk into meetings and spend 10 minutes asking for background. Danira fixed that by sending me a briefing 10 minutes before every call: Who they are, what we promised, and what I need today. No context meant no meeting.

  2. Accountability Layer: We built a system to capture every promise I made on a call so the next step was in motion by the time I hung up.

This system is how we scaled YML to $100M+ without me burning out.

Do you have a specific framework for your calendar, or are you just playing Tetris?

reddit.com
u/Remarkable-Pair8389 — 3 months ago

I've hired EAs for 14 years. Here's what I wish every founder knew before hiring one

I’ve spent 20 years as an executive and built a company to 600 people. I’m posting this here because founders often treat the EA role as admin support, and it is a fatal mistake.

A great EA is a partner and a chief of staff in training. If you’re a founder looking to hire, trust is your only currency. If you aren't willing to give them access to your email and your messy thoughts, you aren't ready for leverage. You also need to realize that onboarding is a 3-month sync. You aren't teaching a schedule; you are teaching a mental model so they know why you prioritize one thing over another.

A great EA tells you "no" more than "yes." I’ve had partners in my business, but my EA was the partner who actually allowed me to build.

For the EAs in this group, what is the number one thing you wish your executive understood about your role?

reddit.com
u/Remarkable-Pair8389 — 3 months ago

In 2014, my calendar at YML was entirely red. I was doing 11 back-to-back meetings a day and eating lunch over a keyboard.

I told myself it was "hustle," but really, I was just a bottleneck. That changed when I hired my EA, Danira.

Most founders think an EA is for booking flights. Danira didn't care about the flights. She cared about why I was meeting a VP at 4 PM on a Friday when I should have been focused on the next hiring round. She knew what we discussed six months ago and what I needed to achieve in the next 30 minutes before I even opened my laptop.

She wasn't an assistant; she was the only person in the building who managed my context so I could actually lead. Because she handled the cognitive load of the small things, I finally had the space to handle the $10M decisions. If you are a founder and you're still the one trying to find a time for a Zoom call, you are costing your company money.

Who runs your calendar right now, and how much strategic time are you losing to admin work?

reddit.com
u/Remarkable-Pair8389 — 3 months ago
▲ 2 r/ExperiencedFounders+1 crossposts

At what revenue stage did you hire an EA, and what did it actually change?

I’ve seen founders hire an EA at $500k ARR, and I’ve seen some wait until $50M. When I was building YML, I waited way too long because I thought I was being "scrappy."

Looking back, it was just ego. I spent three years doing $20/hour tasks while trying to build a $100M company. The math simply didn't work. The moment I finally brought on a professional to handle the operational overhead of my life, my effectiveness as a CEO tripled. Not because I worked more hours, but because the hours I worked actually mattered.

I’m curious about the different philosophies here. Some say hire an EA the moment you can afford it. Others say wait until you're drowning.

For those who have made the hire, what was the revenue trigger? And for those who haven't, what’s the biggest hurdle holding you back?

reddit.com
u/Remarkable-Pair8389 — 3 months ago