Running a "free audit" funnel for local home service businesses — 450 clicks, 0 bookings. What am I missing?
Running Meta ads for a Chattanooga-area marketing agency I built on GHL. The offer: a free "Lead Leak Audit" — we show a home service business owner (pet care, contractors, etc.) how many calls/leads they're losing to missed calls and slow follow-up, then pitch a $297/mo missed-call text-back + AI chatbot + CRM package if they like what they see.
Here's the actual path I'm putting a cold lead through, step by step:
- Ad copy promises something instant: "we'll show you exactly how many leads you're losing, free."
- Click sends them to a landing page — stats, the offer explained, no pitch language.
- The only CTA on that page is a GHL calendar embed: pick a 20-minute slot and hand over your phone number.
- Once they book, we text them a short VSL — a video meant to prime them for the call so it feels worth their time.
- On the call itself we show their real numbers live (phone response time, review gap vs. competitors, AI visibility) — no pitch until they've seen it and want more.
Numbers so far: ~450 landing page views, 2.5-3.8% CTR (feels solid), and exactly zero bookings. Pixel/CAPI tracking confirmed working, calendar widget loads fine on desktop. So it's not a tracking or targeting issue as far as I can tell — people just aren't booking once they land.
Laid out like that, step 3 is the part that bugs me: the ad promises something instant, but the very first thing I ask for is a 20-minute calendar commitment and their phone number — before they've gotten anything. The VSL that's supposed to build trust doesn't even show up until after they've already said yes to the call. So the one payoff moment in the whole funnel comes after the highest-commitment ask, not before it.
Thinking about swapping that first CTA for a quick quiz/calculator — a few taps, gives them an instant "you're losing about $X/month" number — and only then asking them to book. Basically moving a version of that payoff earlier, before the big ask.
Anyone run something similar — an audit/diagnostic offer that converts on cold traffic? What actually got people to book, and did a quiz/lower-commitment step before the calendar make a real difference for you? Also open to "your offer just isn't compelling enough" if that's the real answer.