Is it just me, or is the criticism around Raycast v2 really starting to pile up?
Hey everyone,
I’ve been noticing a pretty clear shift in sentiment within the Mac community lately regarding the direction Raycast is taking—especially with the announcement and rollout of Raycast v2.
While Raycast has been the darlings of the macOS productivity space for a while now, it feels like the community is becoming increasingly divided. From what I’ve gathered across forums and threads, the criticism mainly boils down to three big points:
1. Moving Away from "Mac Native" (Web Tech / React UI)
The biggest source of backlash seems to be the architectural shift.
- Raycast gained its loyal following by being a lightning-fast, purely native Swift app built specifically for macOS.
- With v2, they’ve transitioned to a hybrid stack incorporating web views/React to facilitate cross-platform development.
- Mac purists are concerned this will lead to a loss of that snappy "Apple-native" feel, potential rendering delays, UI inconsistencies, and the overall soul of a true Mac app.
2. Shift in Focus Toward Windows / Cross-Platform
There’s a growing feeling among Mac users that macOS is taking a backseat.
A massive amount of engineering resources has gone into porting Raycast to Windows.
Many feel that macOS innovation slowed down over the past year simply because the team was bogged down rewriting the core architecture just to accommodate other operating systems.
3. RAM Usage and Performance
Even though the Raycast team claims they haven't built a bloated Electron app (it's a custom optimized stack), they have acknowledged that v2 uses more RAM than v1. For an app meant to sit quietly in the background as a lightweight Spotlight replacement, any increase in resource usage is a hard pill to swallow for power users.
Despite that, I’ve seen a noticeable number of long-time users talking about jumping ship back to Alfred or even sticking to Spotlight.
What are your thoughts? Have you noticed a hit in performance or battery life with v2, or do you think the backlash is blown out of proportion? Are you sticking around, or looking at alternatives?