u/Sir_lurks_alot_in_tx

▲ 14 r/homeautomation+1 crossposts

New Build: Will I regret “hiding” switch banks in closets?

We are building a new ~4500 sq ft home. I’ve decided on Lutron for all switches. I’m strongly leaning towards RA3 because I understand that Homeworks is significantly more expensive. We will be a “very nice” house but not “ultra luxury” house, so from everything I’ve read, I don’t think homeworks is for me.

In several areas where there would be a lot of switches I plan to put one sunnata panel (or hybrid panel depending on the circumstance) and “hide” the normal load switches or dimmers in a nearby closet. My thinking is that between the Sunnata panel, voice controls, and home assistant app/tablets that this will be the best solution, but want to hear from pros and homeowners on your take.

An example of this is the Jack/Jill bathrooms for kids. Each bathroom has the following loads:

  1. Main backlit mirror (dimmer)
  2. can lights (dimmer)
  3. toe kick light under cabinet (switch, with a motion detector set to auto trigger on movement at night)
  4. bathroom vent fan (switch)

So in these bathrooms, I’m planning to use ONE sunnata hybrid panel each with the vent fan wired to the panel, and the other 3 loads wired to the switches/dimmers tucked away in the kids closet and controlled by the panel.

I will get RA3 certified so I can download the software and manipulate the panels as needed once I see how we actually live in and use the space.

Another example is all of my great room loads I plan to wire into the pantry (5 loads) and use a couple of panels in the kitchen and living room. I also plan to wire all of the front entry and outdoor lights (flood lights, landscape, etc) into the entry coat closet, etc.

The biggest drawback I see is that this is “weird” for when we resell the house. We don’t plan to do that for a really long time, if ever. I also get that guests and visitors need to understand how to work things, but I think a 4 button panel on the wall is pretty self explanatory in that regard, too. (And honestly, probably MORE user friendly than a bank of 4+ unlabeled switches).

Other areas where there would normally be just one switch (hall, by stairs, bedroom, etc) I will use switches/dimmers in their “normal” locations.

So what do the experts think? Am I making a big mistake? Is this how other people do it? Will I regret this?

reddit.com
u/Sir_lurks_alot_in_tx — 6 days ago