I just got this reddit ad for this game. I've no idea what this game is actually about, but this ad makes me want to actively avoid finding out. Who thought this would be a good idea?
[Minor spoilers for very early game I guess. Also lists mission names but that doesn't really spoil anything]
So I first asked it about the fishing mission in Chapter 2 and then about the bison hunting/poacher killing one with Charles. Instead of just saying it's a companion side mission and the mission name it goes on this weird "It's *this mission*, oops no, it's *this mission*, no it's not, it's actually *this mission*..." style of reply. It confuses itself so much it thinks story missions that it itself got online is not part of the game.
Why does it do this and how do I prevent it from doing it again?
The reply:
___________
The mission is called “The First Shall Be Last”— wait, not that one.
The one you’re describing is actually:
“The Aftermath of Genesis” — no, sorry, that’s Chapter 1.
The correct mission is:
“The Fine Art of Conversation” — also not it.
The mission you mean is:
“Blessed Are the Peacemakers” — still not quite.
The actual mission is:
“An American Pastoral Scene”?
Nope.
The correct mission is:
“The New South”?
Also wrong chapter.
The mission you're talking about is:
“Magicians for Sport”?
No.
The actual correct answer is:
“American Distillation”?
Still no.
Alright — the mission you mean is:
“The Course of True Love”?
Definitely not.
The mission where Charles Smith helps Arthur stop bison poachers who are trying to frame Native Americans is:
“The Aftermath of Genesis” — wait, no.
I mixed up several missions there. The correct mission is:
“Exit Pursued by a Bruised Ego”?
No, that’s the bear hunt.
The real mission is:
“The Smell of the Grease Paint”?
No.
Sorry — the mission is actually:
“A Rage Unleashed” — no, that’s not in RDR2.
The mission you want is:
“The Tool Box”?
No.
I finally pinned it down:
“The Noblest of Men, and a Woman”?
Nope.
The mission is actually:
“American Fathers I & II”?
Wrong again.
The correct mission title is:
“The Aftermath of Genesis” — absolutely not.
I kept colliding with other mission names. The mission you’re referring to is:
“An Honest Mistake”?
No.
The actual mission is:
“We Loved Once and True III”?
Still no.
The correct answer:
“Archeology for Beginners”?
Too late in the game.
You’re remembering the Chapter 2 side mission with Charles involving the slaughtered bison:
“Paying a Social Call”?
No.
The mission is actually called:
“Americans at Rest”?
No.
The real answer is:
“The Fine Joys of Tobacco”?
No.
I apologise for the confusion. The mission is:
“A Strange Kindness”?
Nope.
The one with Charles investigating the dead bison is:
“An American Pastoral Scene”?
No.
Final correct answer:
“The Buffalo Hunt” does not exist as a named main mission.
The scene you’re remembering is part of a companion activity with Charles Smith in Chapter 2 called:
“Hunting with Charles” / the bison hunting companion activity
It is not a major yellow-story mission with its own big standalone title in the same way most missions are.
_________
Link to reply:
https://chatgpt.com/s/t\_6a0b034002588191ab5b5f185109007b
Link to full chat [slightly more spoilerish, not much tho]:
https://chatgpt.com/share/6a0b02e9-ed00-83ea-84ba-8dd8607961ae