u/SouthSideHawkMan117

Should Kyle Davidson make a move for Simon Edvinsson?
▲ 3 r/hawks+1 crossposts

Should Kyle Davidson make a move for Simon Edvinsson?

With all the rumors that Simon Edvinsson wants out of Detroit, I think Kyle Davidson should be all over this situation.

Edvinsson was drafted 6th overall in 2021 and has developed into exactly the type of defenseman the Blackhawks are missing. He's 6'6", skates exceptionally well for his size, can move the puck, play heavy defensive minutes, and match up against top competition every night. His defense is the needle mover.

What makes him so valuable isn't the offense. It's the defensive game. A game the Hawks sorely lack.

Edvinsson uses his reach, size, and gap control to kill plays before they become dangerous. He defends entries extremely well, plays a physical game without running around chasing hits, and has established himself as a legitimate shutdown defenseman. Those players aren't easy to find, especially at 23 years old.

The puck-moving ability is underrated too. He's the type of defenseman who can help a team spend less time defending and more time attacking. Which is missing on the Hawks backend.

So what's the cost?

Probably something close to what Calgary paid for Simon Nemec: two 1sts, a 2nd, and a prospect/player. That's not cheap, but elite young defensemen never are.

The Hawks also have a surplus of young defensemen. Someone is eventually getting squeezed out. If I'm Davidson, I'm absolutely willing to move Wyatt Kaiser, a 1st, a 2nd, and another quality prospect if that's what it takes.

Then your defense suddenly looks like:

Byram - Levshunov
Vlasic - Edvinsson
Cole - Rinzel

That's a pretty ridiculous blend of size, mobility, and defensive ability.

The next question is the contract.

Edvinsson is probably looking for something in the neighborhood of $8-10 million AAV on a long-term deal. Under the new cap, that's simply what young top-pair defensemen cost.

The other interesting option is still Alexander Nikishin, who is reportedly looking for a similar payday. Don't look now but the Canes are really missing him already this season. Personally, I'd be pursuing both situations aggressively because true top-pair defensemen rarely become available at 23 years old.

Let's hope Detroit doesn't solve its problem by sending Edvinsson somewhere like Carolina for a 1-for-1 swap involving Nikishin.

u/SouthSideHawkMan117 — 8 days ago
▲ 16 r/hawks

Should Kyle from Chicago make a move for Cutter Gauthier?

After matching Leo Carlsson's massive five-year offer sheet, the Anaheim Ducks still have work to do. Cutter Gauthier is due for a large raise and remains unsigned. Who are some players that may need to be traded in order to clear cap space for their top goal-scorer, and can the Hawks benefit?

https://thehockeynews.com/news/latest-news/exploring-ducks-trades-to-clear-space-for-a-cutter-gauthier-extension

u/SouthSideHawkMan117 — 2 months ago
▲ 30 r/hawks

If Nikishin Wants $8M+, Should the Blackhawks Be Interested?

Apparently, the Hurricanes and Alexander Nikishin are having trouble finding common ground on a new contract, with reports suggesting he's seeking more than $8 million per year. The Blues and Rangers have both reportedly shown interest if negotiations continue to stall.

There haven't been any reports linking the Blackhawks to Nikishin, but should they be kicking the tires?

At just 24 years old, Nikishin is coming off an impressive season and a Stanley Cup run, and he's widely viewed as one of the most intriguing young defensemen in hockey. The Hawks have built a strong pool of young talent, but adding a proven top-pair defenseman entering his prime could accelerate the rebuild and provide a major boost to the blue line.

Would you be willing to pay Nikishin $8M+ annually if you're Kyle Davidson? Or is that too steep for a team that's still developing and not quite ready to contend?

thehockeywriters.com
u/SouthSideHawkMan117 — 2 months ago
▲ 0 r/hawks

Kyle Davidson Is Still Rebuilding Like It's 2022 While the Rest of the NHL Has Moved On

The last month has absolutely torched whatever confidence I had left in Kyle Davidson's vision for this team.

As a Blackhawks fan, my belief that we're anywhere close to icing a legitimately competitive roster is at an all-time low.

First, let's talk about the Bowen Byram trade. I don't necessarily have a problem with moving the 4th overall pick for an established NHL player. Prospects are lottery tickets, and not every rebuild needs another teenager. But if you're going to cash in a premium asset, shouldn't you be getting an elite player in return? I’m not convinced Byram is that guy, and I'm even less convinced that was the right price.

More concerning is Davidson's complete inability to find a legitimate running mate for Connor Bedard.

Bedard is heading into his fourth season. Fourth.

At some point, the endless excuses about "sticking to the plan" stop being reassuring and start sounding like a guy reading from a script. The franchise was gifted a generational talent and Davidson still hasn't found him a top-line winger capable of maximizing his offensive potential. That's roster malpractice.

Meanwhile, the rest of the league appears to be figuring out that draft picks are massively overrated compared to proven NHL talent. Danny Briere's aggressive move for Leo Carlsson is exactly the kind of swing that changes a franchise's trajectory. It sends a message: stop hoarding futures and start acquiring players.

The market is changing, and Davidson seems determined to operate like it's still Year One of the rebuild.

I've already seen multiple articles suggesting Pen's GM Kyle Dubas should make a monster offer for Bedard. Let's pretend he actually does. What are the Hawks getting back? Four late first-round picks? Congratulations, you've traded Connor Bedard for the opportunity to maybe draft a future Connor Bedard. Makes perfect sense.

And if Bedard ever reaches the point where the Hawks have to match some astronomical offer, that's another problem entirely, one that became exponentially harder because management has spent years failing to build a winning environment around him.

At this point, Kyle Davidson feels like the intern who wandered into Stan Bowman's office one day, got promoted to the big chair, and never updated the PowerPoint presentation he brought to the interview.

He came in with a plan. Fine.

The problem is the league changed and the plan didn't.

Teams are valuing NHL talent more and draft picks less. Smart GMs are adapting. Davidson is still collecting futures like it's a hobby.

Good luck, Kyle.

You're going to need a lot more than another draft pick to get yourself out of this one.

reddit.com
u/SouthSideHawkMan117 — 3 months ago
▲ 0 r/hawks

Should the Hawks kick the tires on Pettersson if the Canucks are this desperate?

It feels like the Nuckleheads have reached the "we'll take anything that isn't nailed down" phase of the Pettersson saga.

If KD can't shake loose a legit top-6 forward through other avenues, should the Hawks take a swing? Sometimes a guy just needs a change of scenery, and let's be honest, Vancouver has become a tire fire that could make anyone look miserable.

Hypothetically, if the Canucks ate $3.6M AAV for the remaining six years, would you do it? At that point you're getting a talented player on a discounted deal and betting that a fresh start unlocks the guy everyone thought he was.

Seems like a package of a 2nd-rounder and a decent prospect might get it done if Vancouver is truly in salary-dump mode. Worst case, you're out a prospect and a pick. Best case, you've stolen a top-line talent because another franchise is panicking.

Am I crazy, or is this exactly the kind of buy-low gamble a rebuilding team should be making while everyone else is running away from the asset?

Should KD take another big swing and big risk?

reddit.com
u/SouthSideHawkMan117 — 4 months ago
▲ 14 r/hawks

It might be wise for Kyle to sit free agency out altogether.

This NHL Free Agency Class is a war crime against cap space. We've hyped up “big moves,” convinced ourselves this was the year. Kyle's best decision should be not to sign deals to guys whose best highlight is “was on a playoff team once.” I’ve seen deeper talent pools in a beer league at 11:30 PM. If Danny Boy were smart, he'd turn off Kyle's phone before FA begins.

https://www.dailyfaceoff.com/news/top-50-nhl-ufas-ranking-list-news-rumors-tuch-andersson-bobrovsky-ovechkin-carlson-jenner-trouba-marchment-kane

reddit.com
u/SouthSideHawkMan117 — 4 months ago