1st year as a YES fan - first takes
I got into Yes - to my embarrassment - just a year ago, in my late 30s (and yes, I am a prog rock fan). Loved Tull, Floyd, Crimson and etc. for years, but Rush and Yes I could never get into. I knew there must be something in it, but I wasn't getting it. I finally got it, and here's few takes I wanted to share:
- AI helped me - I described my favorite albums to ChatGPT asking how should I approach Yes. It told me to start with "Drama". It was a great advice as I really liked it and it opened me up for "Going for the One" and then the earlier stuff.
- Some of the "epic" Yes songs suffer a bit from lack of focus/ideas - e.g. Awaken. The 1st half of this song is probably the most beautiful thing I have ever heard. The middle section is intriguing and captivating. Then they get to the ending and it really is un-satisfactory. Sometimes they want to do too much, take too much time on the LP and they simply don't have enough engaging ideas to keep the same level of excitement for 20 mins. I still like the song overall very, very much, but sounds to me like they lacked the ideas for a grand finale - they did better with "Gates of Delirium" and the perfect example would be something like "Ommadawn part 1" by Oldfield. This may sound crazy, but even "Mirror to the Sky" I think is more "tight" and well-structured as a song.
- Speaking of "MTTS" -> having listened to most of their albums now (I still have the 90s albums to go through, but first attempts were very disappointing) I must say that "Aurora" and "MTTS" are absolutely awesome. Putting nostalgia for the 70s sound aside, this is among the best music they ever made. I had a hard time accepting Davison's falsetto, but once I got over that hump and listened to these albums multiple times I must admit they are excellent, well-written, tight, engaging, atmospheric and in my top6 of all their albums (with Fragile, GFTO, Drama, CTTE). Btw, while as a whole this album is not as good, the Fly from Here suite is also among their best long pieces I heard.