u/StyleOk5093

Need Advice: Keep My Nettle Bay Airbnb or Find Something Else?

I'm planning a solo trip to Saint Martin for my birthday around New Year's and currently have an Airbnb booked at Nettle Bay Beach Club.

I was originally hoping to stay in Grand Case or Orient Bay, but there aren't many options left for the holiday. One of the things I love about my current Airbnb is that it's right on the water. I keep picturing waking up on my birthday with an ocean view, and that sounds perfect.

I've also been told the French side is probably a better fit for me since I'm not much of a partier. I don't mind visiting busier areas during the day, but I'd rather have a quieter home base to come back to.

My only hesitation is safety. I've read older posts saying to avoid Sandy Ground, even driving through it, but I've also seen people say that's outdated and the area has changed.

For anyone who's visited recently or lives on the island:

• Would you feel comfortable staying at Nettle Bay Beach Club as a solo female traveler?
• Is the area generally safe during the day and at night?(I expect to come back to the Airbnb after dark at least 2 times during my stay)
• Has Sandy Ground improved, or is it still somewhere you'd avoid?
• If you were in my shoes, would you keep the booking or try to find something else?

I'd really appreciate recent experiences or local advice. Safety is my top priority, but I'd also love to keep that peaceful waterfront birthday experience if it's a reasonable choice. Thanks!

I’m planning a solo trip (my first international) to Saint Martin for my birthday, which is New Year’s Eve. Since it’s a peak holiday, I’m trying to get a realistic idea of what to expect before booking.

Main questions: •How safe is it for a solo female traveler during NYE specifically? •Would you recommend a hotel or Airbnb for that week? •Is it better to rely on taxis/drivers vs renting a car during the holiday? •Is it still comfortable to dine alone and do low-key activities during that time?

I’m not really into partying..more beaches, food, and relaxing.

I’m also planning to visit Anguilla. Is it worth staying overnight there, or is it more of a day trip situation?

Budget is a little flexible since it’s a birthday trip, but I’d like to stay practical where I can.

Would really appreciate any honest experiences or advice 🙏