on scientific research
I was reading a vintage (1999) National Geographic and came across an interesting article about biodiversity in Peru.
Given that it's a physical magazine and I can't find an online version, I'm going to give the gist of it below. Here is the overview of the main scientist, Terry Erwin, and his legacy, so that you know I'm not just making things up. If you ctrl+f for 'Fogging' it explains it: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8222209/
Gist of the article:
They were trying to determine the number of species of insects in a given column (floor to canopy) of the Vilcabamba rainforest. They way they did this was to use insecticide to gas an area, then document whatever dead insects fell to a tarp prepared near the ground. Here is an excerpt describing it:
>Erwin starts up the fogger and aims it at the night sky. The roar of the motor rips through the forest while an acrid blue-white cloud rises in a narrow column above the first sheet. Lazily, the deathly cloud passes through layers of spindly, broad-leaved shrubs, engulfing every leaf and twig. It swirls over the tops of the lacy fronds of palms and tree ferns and climbs up the smooth-sided trunk of a giant fig tree to the tips of its branches and the stars beyond. Within seconds insects begin to spill from their resting perches onto the sheet below.
The purposes of this was to measure the biodiversity of the forest. The article made note that research like this can yield many benefits for us, such as the discovery of an enzyme in Yellowstone that is incredibly useful for DNA replication.
I'm somewhat torn. The research certainly seems worthwhile, particularly for conservation IMO, and I cannot think of a different way to survey the canopy. It's 100ft off the ground. Still, killing a shitton of insects "for science" seems, well, less than ideal. Especially so since rare and endemic species could be harmed in the process. Of course, we wouldn't know about those species at all without this research.
Curious what other vegans think. Should research like this be conducted? What precautions should or could be taken? Obviously this is peripheral to animal rights issues like agriculture, but I thought it would make for an interesting discussion.