












Sourdough Preferment Experiment, Sourdough Biga vs Sourdough Liquid Starter
This was supposed to be a controlled test of my sourdough for Neapolitan Pizza, basically I am trying to bring consistency and big airy crusts, but I had a number of issues in the run up to this, including my kebabs taking an hour longer than planned, which on a hot day overproofed my dough, so they are not up to my usual standards.
This is a Sourdough version of Biga vs Poolish, both with 20% of the final dough.
It is not a Pasta Madre / Lievito Madre which is Italian for mother dough or mother yeast. Whilst these are typically stiff Biga level hydrations (45-50%), I would have needed at least 6 feeds to change the cultures, so both doughs were still from the same microbial population.
Result Summary
Overall there were differences at different stages, the liquid starter was stronger smelling, the doughs looked and felt exactly the same during the stretch and folds, the biga dough balls surprisingly grew more during both the cold proof and after the fridge, as I over proofed them the Biga was slightly harder to work with because it possibly because it peaked earlier as it had an extra hour at room temperature before the cold proof. No taste difference nor difference in crusts.
Ultimately the difference was not noticeable enough for me to attempt this again, certainly not at 20%. Maybe the sourdough would be worth a try in a 100% Biga recipe like Ooni do, but in all honesty a Pasta Madre / Lievito Madre would be best for a noticeable difference.
Photos
Jars: LS Left, SB Right
All Doughs: SB Left, LS Right
Pizzas: SB Mozzarella, LS Pepperoni
SB:- Sourdough Biga
SD:- Liquid Sourdough
Full breakdown of recipes and steps below:
Sourdough Biga (45% hydration)
• 24.2 g ripe 100% hydration starter (15% Inoculation)
• 68.4 g 00 flour
• 24.2 g water
15% inoculation (starter flour as a percentage of preferment flour) = starter flour 12.1 / total preferment flour 80.5g (12.1+68.4)
Totals:
• Flour = 80.5 g
• Water = 36.2 g
• Hydration = 45%
The biga should be crumbly and only just come together when squeezed.
Final dough
Add to the ripe biga:
• 991.0 g 00 flour
• 660.3 g water
• 32.1 g salt
Total
• Total flour = 1,071.5 g
• Total water = 696.5 g
• Hydration = 65%
• Salt = 3%
Sourdough Liquid Starter (100% hydration)
• 161 g ripe 100% hydration starter
This gives:
• Total flour: 80.5 g
• Total water: 80.5 g
• Hydration: 100%
The sourdough should be risen.
Final dough
Add to the ripe sourdough:
• 991 g strong flour
• 616 g water
• 32.1 g fine sea salt
Method (Both)
Prepare the final starters from active starter
Thursday Night
6am Thursday
Preferment Rest Time = 14 hours
Prepare Final dough
Both doughs to be mixed in the Ooni Halo Spiral Mixer until they reach 22C
Start with the Biga first as it has a slower fermentation.
Thursday Night
6:00 Dissolve Salt in 100ml of boiling water for Mix 1 & 2 (120 mins)
8:00 Mix Biga Starter in the water less 100ml (7 mins)
8:07 Add flour and give it a rough mix (3 mins)
8:10 Rest for (20 mins)
8:30 Final Mix until smooth / 22C adding salt water slowly (5 mins)
8:35 Rest Mix 1 (Biga) on the counter
8:40 Mix Liquid Starter in the water less 100ml (7 mins)
8:47 Add flour and give it a rough mix (3 mins)
8:50 Rest for (20 mins)
9:10 Final Mix until smooth / 22C adding salt water slowly (5 mins)
9:15 Rest Mix 2 (Liquid Starter) on the counter
Stretch and folds for both doughs whilst on the counter. Both doughs should be rested until 20-30% volume increase 2.5 - 3.5 hours
12pm Ball dough, place them in trays, and put them in the fridge for a cold Proof
34 hour cold proof
Saturday
10am Saturday Remove from Fridge
Rest until 14:30 - Start Cook