▲ 3 r/Essay_Experts+2 crossposts

Common App essay draft: looking for honest feedback

Just finished my first draft and would love some honest feedback on the story, voice, flow, and whether it actually feels memorable/personal.

Happy to exchange essays and give feedback in return. Prefer sharing through DMs for privacy. Thanks! :)

reddit.com
u/Training-Outcome-352 — 8 days ago
▲ 1 r/ChanceMeInternational+2 crossposts

Chance Me (Intl, potential merit aid), for JHU/Ivy+ Pre-Med list, 20 schools, ED/EA/RD strategy help needed

Demographics / Stats
Graduation: 2027
Academics: Valedictorian. Grade 10: 94%, Grade 12 predicted: 96%+
Intended Major: Pre-Med track, Biology/Human Health, long-term goal is med school and a career as a physician

Testing
SAT: not yet taken, sitting in September 2026, practicing consistently around 1550 on recent practice tests
TOEFL: 120 (also have DET at 160)

Awards
A biological, sustainable, low-cost water filtration and purification device (installed in 15 villages, 9 schools, 1800 households), Winner two years running at the National Science Fair (patent in progress)
Wipro Scholar recognition, two years running, for the water filtration work
National Innovation Foundation INSPIRE Award
2nd Runner Up, Columbia University CIC paper contest, for research on the neurobiological and psychosocial desynchronization of adolescent development from async home-based learning
International Debate Championship, best team and top speaker, two years running
Win at a Centenary International Conference

Research
Contributed to the IEEE P2933/UL 2933-2024 clinical IoT interoperability standard (TIPPSS framework), literature review and resource development for a Digital Twins Initiative
Working toward publication of an AI-driven diagnostic prediction paper for cancer and diabetes in high-risk and pediatric populations
Cancer research exploring herbal and natural approaches to risk reduction

Clinical Experience
Approximately 200 hours shadowing in ER, bloodwork, and radiology, summer of junior year
Shadowed a cardiologist and a dermatologist, personally connected to managing my own chronic illness

Leadership
Built and led a 150+ student medical sciences community in
Founded and ran a large-scale cybersecurity and online safety awareness campaign in partnership with law enforcement, reaching tens of thousands of students annually with measurable drops in cyberbullying and increases in reporting
Biweekly NGO outreach across 20+ partner organizations, reaching 1,000+ underprivileged students annually with biology education and breast cancer/mammogram awareness advocacy
Opened an NSDC chapter in partnership with Columbia University, worked on digital twins and an IEEE network internship
Three years volunteering with the American Diabetes Association summer camp

Recommendation Letters
Four secured (should be decent)

My List (20 schools)
Brown, Case Western Reserve, Columbia, Duke, Emory, George Washington, Johns Hopkins (dream school, ED/EA), Northwestern, Rice, Saint Louis University, Tulane, University of Chicago, University of Miami (considering swapping with Dartmouth or something), University of Michigan, University of Pennsylvania, University of Pittsburgh, University of Rochester, Vanderbilt, WashU St. Louis, Yale

What I need feedback on
1. Given the profile above, realistically where do I stand across this list, and does it look properly tiered?
2. JHU is my genuine dream and I’m considering ED, but I need to make sure I’m not shutting out better financial aid outcomes elsewhere by locking in early. Anyone dealt with this specific tradeoff as an international applicant?
3. Is my list missing anything given I need real merit aid as an international student, not just need-blind status?
4. With SAT not finalized yet, should I be leaning RD across the board instead of committing early anywhere?

This comprises a good essence of my profile a few additions yet to come with research/awards. Appreciate any honest read on this, brutal feedback welcome.

reddit.com
u/Training-Outcome-352 — 16 days ago