What is the current status of the Bonanno crew in Montreal, which is, of course, widely referred to as the “Rizzuto crime family”?
I know that over the past couple of decades, it’s been a bloodbath up there, with groups like the West End Gang and the Hells Angels competing for territory and influence. But as of 2026, are they still considered one of the premier organized-crime groups involved in drug trafficking? And beyond drugs, what other criminal enterprises or revenue streams are they known to be involved in?
Was Louis “Lepke” Buchalter an associate of the Mangano (later Gambino) crime family at the time of his death, or was he still an independent operator?
Louis “Lepke” Buchalter is, of course, most famous for being the head of what the media at the time called “Murder Incorporated,” a label that was a mischaracterization of several different criminal outfits involved in carrying out contract killings for various individuals.
Albert “The Mad Hatter” Anastasia, who was the underboss of the Mangano crime family at the time, was closely associated with Buchalter. My question is: was Buchalter technically considered to be “on record” with Anastasia, or was he the last prominent independent Jewish gang leader? By this point, Meyer “the Little Man” Lansky and Benjamin “Bugsy” Siegel had long been associates of the Luciano (later Genovese) crime family as well.
Was Salvatore “Sally Bugs” Briguglio really killed because the FBI questioned him about Jimmy Hoffa’s disappearance, or was the Genovese crime family simply tying up loose ends by eliminating one of its most prolific hitmen?
Who Is Your Favorite Mobster to Research, and Why Is the Answer Peter “Peter Pan” Tuccio?
Free the Real!
As Someone Unfamiliar with Today’s NYC Mafia Landscape, How Would You Rank the Five Families by Current Activity?
Obviously, the Lucchese crime family was recently busted in New Jersey on gambling-related charges, and members of several of the Five Families were also implicated in the NBA gambling investigation in Florida.
If Fate Forced You Into the New York Mafia, Which of the Five Families Would You Choose and Why?
If I were 100% Italian and wanted to be made, I would want to be a part of the Genovese crime family for two reasons. Number one is that my old man (RIP), who was a WASP, did a lot of business with the Genovese crime family in terms of selling them waste management equipment, and he always got a kick out of them. He thought they were nice guys, barring their shady “business practices.” And two, because the Genovese crime family has always been about getting that paper and staying low-key.
How Sophisticated Was Somerville and Boston’s Winter Hill Gang Compared to American Mafia Families?
The Winter Hill Gang was associated with a broad range of criminal activities, including illegal gambling operations, horse-race fixing, the World Jai Alai parking skim, weapons trafficking to the IRA in Northern Ireland, and involvement in the drug trade. However, the gang’s actual role in these enterprises was not always as extensive as its reputation suggested. Horse-race fixing, for example, appears to have been largely connected to Howie Winter personally rather than representing a major organizational operation. Likewise, while Winter Hill had a significant presence in Boston’s criminal underworld, its involvement in narcotics seems to have been focused less on directly importing or distributing large quantities of drugs and more on exploiting other local dealers through threats, intimidation, and protection schemes.
John “Red” Shea is one example that highlights this distinction. Shea has repeatedly portrayed himself as a member of the Winter Hill Gang, but Kevin Weeks has disputed that claim, stating that Shea was not a member of the organization. Instead, Weeks has described him as one of many individuals involved in the Boston and Somerville drug scene who became targets of Winter Hill’s extortion efforts. According to Weeks, Shea’s main connection to the gang was allegedly making protection payments at Triple O’s in exchange for being left alone.
Weeks has described only one other notable encounter with Shea. After Shea became involved in a personal dispute with his then-girlfriend, who was friends with Weeks, she asked Weeks to intervene. Weeks claimed that he arrived armed with a machine gun, and that the display of force was enough to convince Shea to back down.
These examples raise a larger question about the Winter Hill Gang’s reputation versus its actual capabilities. Although the organization became known as one of Boston’s most feared criminal groups, how effective was it really at running the various enterprises associated with its name?
Because of How Terrible Godfather of Harlem and The Westies Is, I Wanted to Make an Appreciation Post for Boardwalk Empire and How It Handled Fictional Gangsters Alongside Historical Gangsters. What Are Y’all’s Thoughts on Boardwalk Empire?
I’ll admit that Boardwalk Empire had its weaker moments in its later seasons, but I still found the final season thoroughly enjoyable despite its rushed pacing. Much of this can be attributed to HBO shifting its focus and resources toward Game of Thrones as it exploded in popularity, leaving Boardwalk Empire with fewer opportunities to fully develop its concluding chapters. Even so, the show’s portrayal of the fictional downfalls of Nucky Thompson, Chalky White, Dr. Valentin Narcisse, and others serves as a powerful reflection of a darker historical transition: the decline of the old guard and the rise of the Young Turk faction of American mafiosi, led by figures such as Salvatore “Charlie Lucky” Lucania and Meyer “The Little Man” Lansky, who emerged as dominant forces after the conclusion of the Castellammarese War and the creation of The Commission.
Anyone else find it bizarre that, at its peak, the Mafia could have just legitimately run its casinos, waste management companies, construction businesses, and other ventures and made millions legally instead of relying on corruption, scams, and sketchy tactics to squeeze every cent out of them?
For example, my old man (RIP) sold waste management equipment to Genovese crime family associate Carmine “Papa Smurf” Franco, whose waste management company generated millions of dollars. They could have simply run the business legitimately by collecting and disposing of trash legally and still made substantial money. Instead, they started taking medical waste and illegally dumping it so they could pocket the higher fees.
Another example is Mafia-controlled construction projects, where materials would be stolen and then resold to contractors on other jobs. Obviously, they were criminals, not Harvard graduates, but it’s still striking that many of these businesses could have been highly profitable on their own. They could have leveraged the Mafia’s influence to gain contracts and a competitive advantage while operating mostly legitimate businesses instead of constantly engaging in overtly criminal schemes.
Joseph “Joe” Valachi, While Well Known Among American Mafia Enthusiasts, Is Actually an Underrated Source of Information on the Early 20th-Century American Mafia
For those who don’t know, Joseph “Joe” Valachi was actually made into the Maranzano (Bonanno) crime family at the height of the Castellammarese War by Salvatore “Little Caesar” Maranzano himself. This is pretty significant, since at the time, almost all of the members of the Maranzano crime family were natives of Castellammare del Golfo or neighboring towns in the Trapani region of Sicily, while Valachi himself was a descendant of “mainlanders” from Campania.
By all accounts, the Maranzano crime family was, at the time, and arguably remains today, the most “traditional” of the Five Families of New York City. During the war, he served as one of Maranzano’s personal bodyguards and as one of his top hitmen. It was actually Valachi who urged Maranzano to allow him and others to guard him with weapons at his Manhattan office, but Maranzano turned down the request because he was already being investigated for tax evasion by the IRS at the time. He was later killed at that same location by a Luciano (Genovese) crime family hit squad.
It was only after the war had settled down that his friend Thomas “Tommy” Lucchese urged him to transfer to the Genovese crime family because they were considered the more accepting family toward “mainlanders.”
I highly recommend anyone interested in Valachi, Maranzano, and the Castellammarese War in general to check out the August 2019 issue of Informer Journal, which discusses all of this and more. Valachi’s own memoir is also incredibly informative.
Link: August 2019 issue of Informer Journal - http://informer-journal.blogspot.com/2019/08/august-2019-issue-of-informer.html
What is the sub’s current consensus on Frank Sheeran of I Heard You Paint Houses and The Irishman fame and his claims?
Before getting into this, I want to acknowledge that Frank Sheeran has been thoroughly exposed as an unreliable narrator. His claims that he was the gunman in the murders of Joseph “Crazy Joe” Gallo and Jimmy Hoffa have been thoroughly debunked or otherwise disproven. That said, it seems like people on this sub have become more receptive to some of his less outlandish stories and anecdotes. What do you all think?
The Genovese Crime Family’s Forgotten Plan to Build a Gambling Empire in Mexico
The American Mafia’s ambitions in Latin America extended far beyond Cuba. While Havana became the most famous example of organized crime’s overseas gambling interests, Mexico was another major target for expansion. The goal was to create a network of casino operations that would bring in enormous profits while establishing a permanent foothold in some of the most important tourist destinations in the region.
The Mexican casino venture was driven by some of the most influential figures in organized crime at the time: Meyer “The Little Man” Lansky, Benjamin “Bugsy” Siegel, Alfred Cleveland Blumenthal, and Frank “The Prime Minister” Costello. Together, they pursued plans to secure lucrative gaming monopolies in Tijuana and Acapulco, two cities with enormous potential for tourism growth and international visitors.
Their negotiations involved Mexican President Miguel Alemán Valdés, whose administration was interested in expanding Mexico’s tourism industry and attracting investment. The proposed arrangement would have allowed the Mafia to establish large-scale casino operations similar to those they had developed in Havana. Tijuana, located directly across from the United States, offered access to a huge American customer base, while Acapulco was becoming one of Mexico’s premier resort destinations.
The project represented a major opportunity for organized crime. A successful casino network in Mexico would have provided a steady source of revenue, political influence, and a strategic base for further expansion throughout the Caribbean and Latin America. It was part of a broader effort by Mafia leaders to move beyond traditional criminal activities and establish themselves within profitable industries such as gambling, tourism, and entertainment.
However, the plan ultimately failed when Alemán became involved in a separate corruption scandal. The controversy ended the negotiations and brought the proposed casino empire in Mexico to a close. The collapse of the agreement effectively ended the Genovese crime family’s ambitions to dominate Mexico’s gaming industry.
At the same time, Mexico played another role in the activities of Lansky and Siegel. Beyond their casino interests, they trafficked heroin into the United States through Mexican routes. Operating from Guadalajara and Mexico City, they relied on associates Max Cossman and Harold “Happy” Meltzer to oversee and facilitate the smuggling network.
The story of the Mafia’s Mexican ambitions shows how organized crime in the mid-20th century operated on an international scale. Their plans were not limited to illegal enterprises alone; they sought control of legitimate industries, built relationships with powerful figures, and attempted to create business empires that stretched across borders. Although the Mexican casino project never reached completion, it remains an important example of the scale of organized crime’s ambitions during this era.
Sources:
The Mafia in Mexico (Part I): https://www.thedope.co.uk/blog/the-mafia-in-mexico-part-i
The Mafia in Mexico (Part II): https://www.thedope.co.uk/blog/the-mafia-in-mexico-part-ii
The Mafia in Mexico (Part III): https://www.thedope.co.uk/blog/the-mafia-in-mexico-part-iii
The Mafia in Mexico (Part IV): https://www.thedope.co.uk/blog/the-mafia-in-mexico-part-iv
The Mafia in Mexico (Part V): https://www.thedope.co.uk/blog/the-mafia-in-mexico-part-v
The “Happy” Hood: https://thenewyorkmafia.com/the-happy-hood-harold-happy-meltzer/
Why did the Five Families effectively forfeit Las Vegas to the Midwestern crime families in the second half of the 20th century? Did Chicago and the Five Families come to some sort of agreement, or did it just happen to end up that way?
reddit.comIs it true that Tony “The Ant” Spilotro aspired to start a crime family in Vegas, as alluded to in Martin Scorsese’s film Casino, or was that just Hollywood doing its thing? I’m not really an expert on the Chicago Outfit, so I’d greatly appreciate some insight.
reddit.comWhy did most American Mafia borgatas outside New York not import Sicilian mobsters (“zips”) to bolster their ranks? Furthermore, were there any prominent zips who rose to significant power in families outside New York?
reddit.comFor Those Who Grew Up Around Wise Guys: Did Everyone Know Who They Were, or Was It Something You Learned Quietly? And Furthermore, Do You Have Any Stories About Interactions You Had With Them?
reddit.comAlternate History Discussion: How might the American Mafia have evolved if Salvatore “Little Caesar” Maranzano had succeeded in arranging the assassinations of Salvatore “Lucky” Luciano, Vito Genovese, and possibly Frank “The Prime Minister” Costello through Vincent “Mad Dog” Coll at his office?
Let me first preface this by noting that, according to Informer Magazine, Capo dei Capi Salvatore “Little Caesar” Maranzano allegedly paid Vincent “Mad Dog” Coll roughly $50,000 to assassinate Salvatore “Lucky Luciano” Lucania, Vito Genovese, and possibly Frank “The Prime Minister” Costello at the same Manhattan office building where Maranzano himself was ultimately murdered by a Lucania (Genovese) family hit squad composed of both Jewish and Italian gangsters after he was reportedly tipped off by Frank Scalice and Thomas “Tommy” Lucchese.
Joseph “Joe” Valachi also recalled in his memoirs that, only days before his death, Maranzano lamented that he would once again have to wage war against the Young Turk faction now led by Lucania, believing their fundamentally different vision for how the American Mafia should operate was impossible to reconcile. At the time, Valachi was a member of the Maranzano (Bonanno) family and served as one of Maranzano’s personal bodyguards and drivers.
Another interesting point for discussion is that Maranzano himself was reportedly under investigation for tax evasion and may very well have become the first major organized crime figure convicted by the IRS before Alphonse “Al” Capone.
I recall reading that the Mafia had a presence in places like Brazil, Venezuela, and Libya (back when Libya was an Italian colony). Are there any other locations I might be missing? Also, which other European countries have a Sicilian Mafia presence?
I once read or heard a story about Mickey Cohen when he was a teenager selling newspapers in Los Angeles. A wealthy older woman looked at him and said something like, “My, what dirty hands you have.” It had a profound impact on his self-image and sense of worth, to the point that once he became a wealthy gangster, he was always dressed to the nines and bathed multiple times a day. Thomas “Tommy” Lucchese also had a similar origin story. He saw his father breaking his back every day for peanuts and essentially promised himself that he would never live like that. Ennio Morricone’s song “Poverty” is also utterly incredible in this scene.