Ranking Every Eurovision Edition of the 21st century purely based on song quality - Part 2 (2010s)
Like the title says, I’m going to be ranking every Eurovision edition since 2000 solely on the quality of the songs, so no stagings or live performances will be taken into account. In order to not make you read the longest Reddit post ever made, I’m splitting it into 3 parts by decade, so this will cover the editions from 2010-2019. Click here for part 1.
In addition to the rankings, I’ll also name my favorite, least favorite, most underrated, and most overrated songs from that year. For the overrated and underrated songs I’ll be factoring in both where it ended in the final standings and also what the general community consensus is.
Please respect that these are just my opinions and are in no means objective. You guys mostly agreed with my 2000s list but I feel like this one will be much more divisive.
#10 - 2011 🇩🇪
Favorite - 🇬🇪 One More Day
Least Favorite - 🇭🇷 Celebrate
Overrated - 🇩🇰 New Tomorrow
Underrated - 🇨🇾 San Aggelos S’agapisa
While not nearly as bad as the worst years from the 2000s, 2011 is definitely the worst edition of the 2010s. A lot of the songs from this year were just very confusing to me and I didn’t really understand the appeal of them, like Boom Boom, I Love Belarus, and Stand By among others. There were some decent songs from this year, but overall it’s a pretty weak year, which was reflected in how widespread the results ended up being.
#9 - 2013 🇸🇪
Favorite - 🇳🇴 I Feed You My Love
Least Favorite - 🇲🇹 Tomorrow
Overrated - 🇦🇿 Hold Me
Underrated - 🇦🇱 Identitet
2013 was just kinda unremarkable for me. The worst songs were bland and the best songs were good but not great. I think it’s because most of the songs were more modern (by 2013 standards) and radio friendly in order to attempt to be more commercially viable like Euphoria was the year prior so they just ended up being not that memorable.
#8 - 2019 🇮🇱
Favorite - 🇦🇿 Truth
Least Favorite - 🇩🇪 Sister
Overrated - 🇷🇺 Scream
Underrated - 🇷🇸 Kruna
This might be a bit controversial but I didn’t like 2019’s selection of songs that much. There was an abnormal amount of nothing burger songs like the Sister by S!sters who weren’t actually sisters, Bigger than us, 22, Heaven, Home, Stay, Limits and I can keep going. I think there’s some good songs here and obviously Arcade was a big hit, but compared to what had come right before and what came after, 2019 doesn’t really hold up.
#7 - 2017 🇺🇦
Favorite - 🇮🇹 Occidentali’s Karma
Least Favorite - 🇪🇸 Do it for Your Lover
Overrated - 🇷🇴 Yodel It
Underrated - 🇱🇹 Rain of Revolution
2017 wasn’t a bad year, but there’s a clear reason why people look at it as a weak year. When 2014, 2015, 2016, and 2018 were so strong, 2017 ends up getting largely forgotten about. With that said, there’s some things to like about this year such as Italy’s greatest song since their return (in my opinion) and a lot of songs that stood out with how unique they were in the context of Eurovision like Rain of Revolution and Amar Pelos Dois.
#6 - 2010 🇳🇴
Favorite - 🇹🇷 We Could Be the Same
Least Favorite - 🇨🇾 Life Looks Better in the Spring
Overrated - 🇦🇿 Drip Drop
Underrated - 🇨🇭Il Pleut de l’Or
I actually quite enjoyed 2010, but the mid-to-late 2010s were so strong that it only lands at the bottom half of this list. Yeah you still had some songs that were extremely dated, but this year produced so many classics and birthed so many legends like Hera Bjork, Lena, Sunstroke Project, and Paula Selling & Ovi amongst others.
#5 - 2016 🇸🇪
Favorite - 🇪🇪 Play
Least Favorite - 🇨🇭The Last of our Kind
Overrated - 🇫🇷 J’ai Cherché
Underrated - 🇪🇪 Play
Now this is where things really get good. When I first listened to the 2016 songs I honestly had a hard time figuring out who my winner is cause there’s so many quality songs at the top between Play (ROBBED), LoveWave, You are the Only One, 1944, and Sound of Silence. Overall there was just a lot of songs I look back at fondly which makes 2016 more memorable for me, but it only gets better from here.
#4 - 2015 🇦🇹
Favorite - 🇦🇺 Tonight Again
Least Favorite - 🇭🇺 Wars for Nothing
Overrated - 🇸🇪 Heroes
Underrated - 🇧🇾 Time
This might also be controversial but 2015 was awesome in my opinion. Yeah a lot of the songs feel a bit generic but they really resonated with me anyway. Like Time and Tonight Again aren’t revolutionary songs but they’re absolute bangers. There’s also the total guilty pleasure of I Want Your Love and who can forget the 2 great songs which are both named Warrior.
#3 - 2014 🇩🇰
Favorite - 🇦🇲 Not Alone
Least Favorite - 🇱🇻 Cake to Bake
Overrated - 🇸🇪 Undo
Underrated - 🇮🇱 Same Heart
I think 2014 is iconic for me because it’s when I first heard about Eurovision as my middle school French teacher was teaching us about it and showed us the song Moustache (which is a banger). With that said, this has got to be the most diverse set of music I’ve seen in Eurovision. Just about every genre is covered and there’s a lot of songs that are very unique and we haven’t heard anything like them since. Besides the 2 awful songs that for some reason both have “cake” in their names, I think just about every song has some great or memorable qualities to them.
#2 - 2012 🇦🇿
Favorite - 🇸🇪 Euphoria
Least Favorite - 🇮🇱 Time
Overrated - 🇷🇺 Party for Everybody
Underrated - 🇨🇭Unbreakable
2012 marked a turning point in the contest where the music really started to feel like it had caught up to the greater music scene around the world. Obviously Euphoria was legendary but so many countries sent my favorite entry of all time for them (🇷🇸🇬🇷🇭🇺🇲🇰) and there’s also a ton of* guilty pleasures like Stay, Woki Mit Deim *Popo, *and Beautiful *Song amongst others. Maybe it’s nostalgia for the fact that my music taste is heavily influenced by what I liked to listen to around 2012, but that edition really delivered for me.
#1 - 2018 🇵🇹
Favorite - 🇨🇭Stones
Least Favorite - 🇸🇲 Who We Are
Overrated - 🇫🇷 Merci
Underrated - 🇲🇪 Inje
And finally we got the first ever Eurovision that I watched, which just so happens to be what I consider the best year in Eurovision history (from a purely musical standpoint). You’d have to get into the 30s of my list to find a song that I think is just ok. Almost every country in 2018 locked in and sent certified bangers.
Eurovision was at its best in the late 2010s with insane quality almost every year. Stay tuned for the conclusion of the series with the 2020s.