I think we did okay playthrough
My husband and I just finished The Quarry. I think we did okay! Lol. We played to what we think the characters would do based on the personality and only ended up having one of the main protagonist die, Jacob, and thats only because my husband didnt quite get the breaker puzzle. Ironic Jacob got them into this mess and the was the only one for us not to make it out...
Overall, it was a great game and really fun to play! We both just felt it had a really abrupt, anticlimactic ending. All that build up and plot points to just fall flat. But, hey, overall we lost almost no characters so Id say pretty okay playthrough.
Now we are looking at replying the game with different decisions or playing Unitl Dawn (backwards from most recommendation).
Also, anyone else have Laura's hair constantly change length in the last chapter? LOL